Comment Re:Fully autonomous or sort of autonomous? (Score 1) 101
Would you drive with a person that stops their car every 5000 miles with 'sorry can't go on here'?
My car only goes about 300 miles before it will stop all by itself anyway. If the driver isn't smart enough to find a safe place to pull over, get out, walk around a bit, maybe refill the fuel tank, then pretending the number "5000 miles" is significant is just silly. All that means is that is how often it takes for them (on average I'm guessing) to get stumped by something they haven't learned yet.
My youngest just got a learner's driving permit. In my experience from teaching young new human drivers, it's really not that different. In the beginning they may make several mistakes per mile. Within a few days or maybe even hours they catch on and the rate drops to maybe one error per session of 5-30 miles. Some states require having a permit and accompanying driver for a full year, though I would feel comfortable letting them go on their own in as little as 3 months. (Disclaimer: I learned to drive as a CDL professional and teach that style to my children. It is a wonderful thing watching teenage drivers with the will power to ignore their phones while driving.) It takes lots of practice to become competent and even still we all make mistakes.
How about roads with no markings, single lane, or gravel roads that are on no map? Or roads with worn markings? Or roads where the map and reality don't match?
Driving a road without markings? Ask a plow driver. The TL;DR version is, you get really good at reading the crown of the road and the ditch contours in fairly slippery and poor visibility conditions. I expect these fancy laser sensors can see in the dark better than I can. If they are just using a webcam, then yeah, I doubt it will end well.
Just a couple weeks ago I was driving a new dirt road that isn't on maps yet. There was quite a steep drop down to the stream below and of course no guardrails. It was a bit too narrow in places, off camber in others, but new so no wash outs yet. Average speed about 20 for me, though the posted limit was 25. Personally I would have posted it 20 or even 15 for the width and limited visibility around hills and curves, but mostly I went slower for the comfort of my aging bones.
Honestly I would be more concerned if the autonomous car didn't stop at the end of the pavement and ask in a little popup window "Are You Sure?" And in true UI-style du-jour, it would have a single "OK" button that you can barely read for the poor contrast and thin font.