The comment indicate a misunderstanding of how stock, real capital (stuff used for production), consumption, worker productivity and consumption works.
Very quick summary, glossing over a lot of detail, and dropping a bunch of "on average", "in aggregate", "mostly", "strongly correlated", and similar qualifiers: The wealth of tech billionaires is held in stocks. The fundamental value of stock is the net present value of the future dividends & repurchases of that stock over the lifetime of the company. As a company can issue stock to get more money which can be used to buy/create real capital, stock valuation directly correspond to real capitalization behind each worker. Worker productivity at the margin is strongly correlated with real capital (production equipment, training, etc), and overall payment is correlated with marginal productivity through the Baumol effect - essentially, workers will work at whatever pays most, thus other employers have to increase pay to match the marginal productivity[1]. We can't take the wealth (stocks) that billionaires hold and spend them for other purposes without decreasing productivity and thus decreasing worker pay. That wealth is a tradable claim on future income, used for investment, and spending it is just shifting from investment to spending. What we can take without decreasing productivity is the consumption that tech billionaires do - we can (and IMO should) tax that very heavily. We could also tax their wealth by just taking away stock to have society have more control or for future income, but selling that stock en masse would decrease capitalization and thus remove income. I'm also in favor of a close to 100% inheritance tax above some reasonable minimum (maybe 10x the median inheritance?) with the usual caveats around capital flight and motivation needing scientific research.
WRT "greed": People often keep stock/money to have flexibility in what they do. They want to start a new type of tech company that they think will make a huge positive difference? Well, they have the resources to do so. I often use Ingar Kamprad, the guy that started IKEA, as an example. He was a billionaire and lived a lower middle class lifestyle, staying in a small house and with a beater car, and in his personal life tried to save similar to how a poor person would - e.g, he was known for trying to make sure that he got his haircuts when he was in a country where that was cheaper than in Sweden. Yet, he kept his billions of IKEA stock until the very tail end of his life, because he had strong opinions on how it should run and wanted to keep the control to run it so it made (in his opinion) the most positive difference. Was that greed?
[1] Before you talk about the disconnect between productivity and wages since the 1970s, note that:
- 1. The decrease in labor's share is to a large degree due to more going to depreciation rather than profit/capital (ie, we're spending a bunch more of our collective time on producing tools that get worn out)
- 2. The scale of the change depends a lot on which inflation measure you use, with CPI creating a larger difference
- 3. We're still seeing a meaningful increase in median real income, even with the CPI as the conversion from nominal to real
- 4. If we look at improvement inside each demographic group, we're seeing large improvement in real income on just about every group except uneducated white men