Before the inevitable "it's because we don't fund the schools enough" let's keep in mind: the city of Minneapolis as an example of a metro area in a high tax, school-supporting state.
Spent $25345 per student
Reading Proficiency
Students perform below the 49.6% statewide proficiency average.
Elementary: Roughly \(38\%\) test at or above proficient.
Middle School: Around \(30\%\) test at or above proficient.
High School: Approximately \(43\%\) test at or above proficient.
Math Proficiency Breakdown - state 45% :Elementary: About \(33\%\) test at or above proficient.
Middle School: Only \(20\%\) test at or above proficient.
High School: Around \(21\%\) test at or above proficient.
Japan $10993 per student
Germany $17996 per student
PISA Scores and Approximate Rankings
(Out of ~70+ participating education systems; OECD averages: Math ~490, Science ~493, Reading ~493)
Mathematics:
Japan: 532 (rank ~5thâ"6th)
Germany: 475 (rank ~24thâ"25th)
United States: 470 (rank ~34thâ"40th)
Japan led with a substantial gap (~57â"62 points over Germany/US).
Science (main focus domain in 2015):
Japan: 538 (rank ~2ndâ"3rd)
Germany: 492â"500 (rank ~16thâ"22nd)
United States: 496 (rank ~16thâ"20th)
Japan again dominant; US and Germany closer but below top performers.
Reading:
Japan: 516 (rank ~3rdâ"8th)
Germany: 480â"506 (rank ~16thâ"21st)
United States: 497â"504 (rank ~9thâ"16th)
Japan strong; US slightly ahead of Germany here.
Approximate Combined Average (for illustration):
Japan: ~529
Germany: ~489â"502
United States: ~488â"490
Probably shouldn't even talk about Japanese scores unless we want to humiliate American educators.
Why does it cost 25% more per student to get scores than Germany ?