Can you give an example of these superior technologies? I think the Cyrix chips were shit (probably not developed to circumvent the export controls, but the right era). What is drawback of making processing inconvenient for nations/groups we don't want to easily encrypt?
It is always completely contrary to American interests, both in the short term and long term:
- It weakens U.S. companies' ability to sell around the world, permanently reducing the world market share for U.S.-made tech.
- Within single-digit years, they're buying similar tech from some other country or building their own anyway, so it has no real medium-term or long-term strategic impact.
- It weakens trade relations with those countries and strengthens trade relations between those countries and the countries that are willing to sell to them.
That last one is crucially important. It's why Iran and Russia are so close now. It's why China and Russia are so close. By keeping certain countries out, it encourages them to form relationships with other like-minded countries, and they become a stronger bloc.
More than that, it discourages the from doing anything that would make them dependent on trade with the United States, which means that if they do something we really don't like, we have almost no economic leverage to force them to stop. When you're dealing with a country that may or may not behave well on the world stage, the ideal situation, at least from a foreign policy perspective, is to maximize those countries' dependence upon the United States while minimizing U.S. dependence on trade with those countries. That way, if they cross a line, you can break them without breaking the U.S., rapidly forcing them to behave themselves.
Isolation for punitive reasons is fine, as long as there's a clear path back to our good graces. Isolation to prevent another country from growing is always detrimental. It only hurts the United States and our strategic interests.