You are completely wrong about the law here, asshole. Please go away.
For anyone else who has read this far down in the thread, what is being alleged is that Ilhan Omar was actually 18, not 17, when her father applied for US citizenship for the family. If she was 18, she should have filed a separate application.
There are multiple problems with the government pursuing a denaturalization case here:
- It's based on a lie - somebody made up the original claim of knowing when she was born.
- It's impossible to prove anything. Somalia was in the midst of a civil war, there are no records.
- The alleged fraud would have been by her deceased father, not her - he's the one who filed the application.
- IT DOES NOT MATTER.
The last point is especially important. The written law and case law for denaturalization is unambiguous: after someone becomes a citizen, the government must demonstrate that any mistaken or fraudulent information would have been significant and material. The state must PROVE that an application would have been almost instantly rejected if the information had been complete.
The only cases where denaturalization has been applied in the past has been for things like former concentration camp guards and direct participants in terrorist organizations.
The facts in this case do not come even close to to what the law requires. In fact, the evidence is that even if she had filed an application as an 18-year-old, it would have been approved.
This entire case is because Stephen Miller and Trump wanted to attack her. Anyone claiming otherwise is an idiot.