Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Sure it is. (Score 2) 16

I'm sure this is improving test scores in cherry picked tests.

I'm pretty confident that what they'll find is that the cell phone ban improves test scores in only tests that involve critical thinking. Basically anything that a distraction would affect. It unlikely affects any test that is multiple choice, or requires physical activity (physical education, shop classes, lab classes (including chemistry and cooking)) though it could be suggested that locking the phone away during shop/labs is a better argument for safety than anything else.

I am pro-cellphone-ban in schools, but that has to be practiced by both the students and the teachers, and has to extend to laptops used by students. During class, Internet is turned off.

I worked for a K-12 school district in an IT support role for 20 years, from late 2001 to early 2022. The problem with technology is that kids don't learn the fundamentals, they learn the specific technology in most cases. Rather than learning how to think about a concept, they learn one specific implementation and might not even build transferrable skills in the process.

Granted, this phenomenon predates digital/electronic devices and software, with a case in point being the library card catalog for pulling records for books sorted by the Dewey Decimal System as opposed to other library sorting systems. But on the other hand Dewey is the most popular library filing system in the US even after the advent of electronic card catalog systems, so it's still useful even if it is specific and not especially transferrable.

As for the idea of turning off the Internet, too much curricula is delivered via Internet now to make that happen. Canvas LMS is basically cloud-only, and Google Classroom tightly integrates with Google Drive/Docs/Sheets and other systems for bringing curricula.

The problem is that we give kids general-purpose computers that let them do almost anything. We attempt to lock-down what they can do but we're imperfect at doing that, and we're imperfect at content-filtering. We tried creating special-purpose educational computers in the past but those generally flopped. We even used to use computers with limited network resources (think the days of campus-wide IPX/SPX networks and little to no WAN connectivity) but again, it's so much easier to deliver the content from the Internet that no one wants to go back to a strictly on-prem model.

I kind of miss the days when one had to get the floppy disk from the teacher and take over to boot it up to game one was going to play. It meant that game was realistically the only thing you could do with the computer for the vast, vast majority of students. So they loaded Number Munchers and did math instead of wasting time on whatever website has barely-educational games and isn't yet blocked by the district's IT department.

Comment Re:The buck stops there (Score 1) 75

Most nuclear power plants require electricity running to pumps to add water, while the radioactive material automatically is there.

perhaps, but how many nuclear power plants have no control-operators and no qualified on-site maintenance workers and no internal closed-circuit alarms and status indicators?

I expect that these days, a hotel pool's maintenance has been so thoroughly outsourced that even the on-site maintenance person isn't really supposed to get involved with it. That maintenance person certainly isn't going to be in a position to be alerted to a chemical imbalance in the water.

Comment Re:Using AI bug discovery and AI patches is great. (Score 1) 42

It doesn't matter how cheap they are when their use is effectively unbounded. Slop purveyors open 1,000 bug reports or PRs?

These models typically cost on the order of 10-20 cents per MILLION tokens in (assuming cache misses!) and ~50 cents per MILLION tokens out. 1/100th the cost of Fable or Astra, for a task that's far less token-hungry than coding. 1000 bug reports or PRs is perfectly handleable. It simply is not an issue.

Secondly, if there's evidence that a bad actor is involved, a model is perfectly capable of asking you if you want to ban them or banning on its own if you give it permission. And if they're behaving in a way that makes them hard to ban (sockpuppeting, etc), likewise asking you / acting on its own to report the attack.

Where do we send our funding requests?

Right here. Note I'm not going to write your harness for you, but if you come back to me with a harness and a serious proposal, I'll totally look at it.

Comment Re:Shifting expectations (Score 1) 43

I can only find a single example in all of history of a person who was fooled by ELIZA, and only in a "he thought it was a remote-working employee taking the piss" way, not in a "he thought a computer was alive" way.

This notion that ELIZA mass-fooled people is simply not in line with the actual reality we live in. Weizenbaum pushed it heavily in his later life because he was an anti-AI zealot (driven in part due to anger about the use of computers for targeting during the Vietnam War, but also because some people started seriously considering the use of a tool like ELIZA/DOCTOR for talk therapy), with his main example being claims that because his secretary wanted to continue using it and asked him to leave the room, she had been stupidly duped into thinking it was alive. Of which Weizenbaum's own daughter later commented:

I always heard that just really kind of soaked in arrogance. Like, how could she be so stupid to think that this is actually a meaningful communication? Here you have somebody who so needs a landing pad for her feelings that she’s willing to embrace it, right? And he totally misses that, he totally misses the human need and instead speaks of just evidence of this person’s stupidity rather than evidence of their humanity.

Literally, before you ever mention ELIZA again, actually try the thing. For more than 30 seconds. The illusion falls apart really, really quickly. It's not fooling anyone. What actually happened is that people tend to break into two groups. One deliberately tries to get the bot to say ridiculous things to prove what it's doing and show it off as the cheap artifice that it is. The other does just the opposite, "role-playing" and deliberately trying to avoid saying things that would cause the bot to break the roleplay, to try to get the conversation to last coherently as long as they can. Neither group is "tricked".

Comment Re:What is this bullshit? (Score 5, Interesting) 100

Odds are they looped the network (I have seen it happen on other wan router upgrades/wan wiring upgrades) it cause severe network havoc and the connections pass thousands fast.. I have also see the network issue cause disconnects and reconnects on the backends and each of those new connections create new processes and use ram and it only takes that going on for a while to crush the backend's cpu and ram (because the old processes do not go away fast enough).

If they managed to loop a network that uses a routing protocol then I'd be very impressed. They are using L3 links, right?

I've dealt with L2 networks that had loops leading to broadcast storms, but the last time I saw a network that used multi-hop L2 across WAN links was a legacy topology that derived from the prior Novell Netware network, with one TCP/IP router across the whole organization for the enterprise zone. It frankly was a shiatshow because even though each site had its own VLAN, the L3 router could end up swamped if there was a loop at any of the nearly 100 sites. For reasons I still don't understand the prior network engineer had disabled spanning-tree to the access port level at the sites as well.

In a L3 network if the routes are configured statically then I could see it being possible to introduce some kind of routing loop, but we've had reliable routing protocols for decades now. We can even construct the network with an overlay/underlay model using older technologies like MPLS or newer ones like EVPN if one wants to get fancy, allowing for the underlay to handle the convergence and other control-plane messaging with the data-plane traffic nicely segmented on the overlay. Juniper supports this, and if there's a mix of HPE and Juniper gear in this network, the HPE stuff should still support it.

So that this happened on a Friday afternoon is unconscionable. This is stuff that should be reserved for a minimal-traffic period if an actual downtime window isn't possible, when as many of the redundant systems (ie older physical radios for controllers to use) are up and on standby. That this happened during one of the busiest times of the week is ridiculous, and the timing alone calls into doubt the claim of what happened.

Comment Re:These people haven't read the Slashdot item (Score 3, Interesting) 43

Basically, the Cray X-MP/2 had 16-32 MB of fast RAM and a then-absurd ~5 GB/s memory bandwidth and a solid state "disk" (actually MOS RAM cache) with 256MB-1GB of storage and a 100-1000 MB/s bandwidth / sub-25-microsecond latency. The DD-39 / DD-49 disk arrays could hold 1,2GB per drive, up to 38GB, 6-10MB/s unstriped or ~50MB/s striped. Honestly, you could readily go with a far larger number of total params, so long as you kept the active params small enough to fit in RAM. An architecture like Freetoken could significantly improve performance as well. Performance would be limited by the 400 MFLOPS of compute, not the bandwidth (really, apart from the fact that all math was 64 bit float, it wasn't a bad architecture for inference!). You'd want to do token batching and maybe add a speculative decoding model to boost performance further.

Of course, you could never train a model like that on the Cray!

Comment Re:These people haven't read the Slashdot item (Score 2) 43

The funny thing is, if we could send the weights and inference back in time, a 1983 Cray X-MP/2 running a 300M–400M total / ~35M–40M active param MoE - probably similar to the reasoning capability of the computer in Wargames - could probably output 1-3 tok/s (or make an equivalent number of reasoned decisions per second with a Jev-like decision head). In Wargames, the computer seems to output at about 3 tok/s.

Who knew that that movie was technologically plausible? ;)

Slashdot Top Deals

Top Ten Things Overheard At The ANSI C Draft Committee Meetings: (5) All right, who's the wiseguy who stuck this trigraph stuff in here?

Working...