Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: At least half true. (Score 1) 35

At some point being faster is a liability if you feel compelled to "make the most of it". Impossible to apply that 'lot of judgement' when you get a gigantic ball of code submitted within a short window of time. I think pointing fingers at the patch is *absolutely* warranted if it turns out that the slopped up patches end up kneecapping the code more often than it happened before. Yes tighter testing discipline is *absolutely* needed, because the patches have gaps that no one is used to expecting, and certainly not going to find in a multi-thousand line merge request submitted by some entry level guy that asked Claude to add some unasked for feature that he thought was 'neat' that touches just tuns of unrelated code for no sane reason (most recently, the guy seemed to induce it to make every call to an external library only be called from a single place and rework all calls in a file to call a 'helper' to call the function from a library, impossible to review volume of code for zero benefit, and offtopic for the alleged meat of his request).

Comment Re:It Gaslights in Natural Language (Score 1) 35

It largely is, and it can be mitigated in many scenarios where an objective test can be run quickly to prove/disprove whether a change worked as intended. This is a critical ingredient in having codegen work, otherwise it will *look* reasonable but have screw-ups. I highly suspect the Microsoft change was likely slopped up and looked reasonable but had a huge gotcha.

But either way, in a vulnerability seeking context, this isn't a huge liability, though it is an inconvenience. Security team started using one of the models on a private codebase and it flagged 60 "issues". Of which, 58 were ultimately not actually issues upon human review, but it found two that had otherwise gone undetected, and two is enough.

Comment Re:Anthropic PR (Score 1) 35

Note that based on what I've seen, while it is certainly true that foreign companies don't get as much value out of their contracts as they would have liked, when they go with the "handshake, money comes later" they can get even more screwed.

Recently saw one such situation where one part of the company was livid that some team had been pushed to do work with neither up front payment or a contract, and the sales team saying "that's just the way things are done culturally here" and surprise, they never got payment.

The "no contracts, just vibes" approach should be an impossibly huge red flag when you get to this scale of operations, even in that region.

Comment Re:Speeding past police roadblock (Score 1) 29

Traffic break, not roadblock. Traffic breaks are when the cops drive slowly weaving back and forth across the road with their lights flashing. Roadblocks are when they stop and block off the road.

Lots of people are confused by traffic breaks: "WTF is this cop doing? Swerving back and forth going real slow on the freeway?" I have seen people try to drive past the cop when they pull to one side, only to have the cop cut back in front of them and use the PA to tell them to "Stay behind me!"

It is not something that is taught in drivers training, or in the drivers handbook, nor is it on the written test. You just learn about it when it happens to you. Most people figure it out quickly enough.

Comment Re:Anthropic PR (Score 1) 35

I agree with that, though huge chances the circular funding won't care which CEO is in charge either. To the extent they think it fuels their bubble, they'll keep at it.

I think there was some indication they started shrinking the circlejerk of funding a few months ago though, causing some of the darlings to have pretty catastrophic crashes when their 'business model' of income just being nVidia money to buy stuff back from nVidia evaporated and they had not proven any viable *actual* business yet on their part.

Comment SK (Score 2) 21

Here in the US education just isn't taken all that seriously. Imagine if the US instituted a nationwide flight stop and opened our markets late for something like the SAT. You'd call someone crazy for suggesting it. And yet, https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/1... They also codified their school phone ban in law. Some schools even disallow phone use on school property even when school is not in session. SK seems to be taking phone addiction seriously.

Comment Re:reach out and touch someone (Score 1) 87

No, because no reasonable customer in 1987 would have expected that slogan to mean their telephone allowed them to stick their hand through it and emerge elsewhere to make physical contact with another person.

The phrase "fiber-powered" on the other hand could be taken by a reasonable customer to mean that there will be fiber running to their home to power their internet connection.

Comment Re:How much of this is due to reduced code quality (Score 1) 42

Well the FAA thing, at least if they are being truthful, sounds something like either a BGP screwup or a broadcast storm (we only get the answer after the telephone game through politicians). Which doesn't rule out AI bullshittery (they could have asked Claude for a good router config and taken it at face value, I know one person who did do that and sent it to a technician and I was able to interject because it did explicitly connect broadcast domains that were supposed to be distinct).

Microsoft and banking are squarely in the realm where AI codegen is likely a component.

In terms of what to look for, for the bullish AI management, it's damn near impossible. Someone submitted a pull request of thousands of lines of code ostensibly for a very minor change. Management is questioning the decision to block it because it's too big to plausibly review and that much change is extremely bad smell for the goal. However 'Claude audited it' so it *should* be good, and are we just being luddites? In my case, we still win in practice by rejecting it, but from public reporting it sounds like some other organizations may not be so fortunate.

Comment Re:Michigan doesn’t run the economy. These d (Score 3, Informative) 85

Worse, according to the article already woefully out of date. The "average" DC in the sample used 40MW * 400 = 16GW. The west texas Kilby plant for microsoft is 2.67GW all by itself. https://constructionreviewonli... If they build 400 of those (and they will) then we are looking at over 1TW of power consumption. Or around 20X what the state of Texas uses. Of course the Kilby project is behind the meter.

Comment Re: I think this amazing... (Score 1) 103

Jury is out on AI in my opinion. I think waymo is still leading the most important application of AI which is self-driving cars. But if Tesla comes back from behind and is able to make millions of cars that work well enough with just cameras that decision could still be vindicated. Or if the little Tesla humanoid robot started to have general utility? Although I think that is a real long. In either case, it's not that Tesla is identified with some breakthrough in AI, but it does have the will and the resources to try to Force through improbable successes. And to say that his win rate is mere chance is just not reality based.

Comment Re:Kessler syndrome seems inevidible (Score 1) 92

Hopefully Amazon, too...

I believe that the FAA won't license an orbital launch unless there's a firm plan for either deorbiting at end-of-life, or moving to a higher graveyard orbit for geosynchronous stuff. That's one of the reasons SpaceX did several non-orbital missions with Starship while they were proving they could reliably relight a Raptor and do a deorbit burn. I think "atmospheric drag" is an acceptable plan if the orbit is low enough and the satellite is small enough that none of it will survive to ground level during reentry.

Slashdot Top Deals

Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed. -- Francis Bacon

Working...