Comment Re:More from the "never happened" department (Score 1, Insightful) 226
My view is different where I take stance that invasion is to forceable take over land to claim ownership of it. Annex might be a better word for what I meant.
Find it hard to believe the "why" of an invasion is even relevant. I can see China invading the western seaboard of the US telling Americans hey no worries we do not "claim ownership". As if any living person in the US would give a flying fuck about such utterances.
The big point is Russia is trying to take ownership of Ukraine, like it has done in many places before. Where as nobody in recent history has tried to claim ownership of Russian. Going back to your post that being a nuclear power does not prevent invasion and then using Ukraine as example, it is a bad example.
In Ukraine's example the nuclear deterrent does not apply because if Russia nuke Ukraine it will likely have same result as surrender.
Front lines are too diffuse for tactical nukes to have much of a strategic effect. Unless Russia plans on lobbing strategic nukes at major population centers which sure as heck is not the "same result as surrender" even nukes are unlikely to result in surrender and may well backfire.
Read up on The Holodomor for what Russia did to Ukraine in the past if really don't understand why the Ukrainians are fighting so hard.
I don't see the relevance WRT invasion claims.
The Ukraine attacks of Russia are because Ukraine has nothing to lose, their choice is risk a fast death vs a likely slow death after surrender.
Being a nuclear power is an effective deterrent to invasion from countries that have something to lose in a counter attack i.e MAD.
"Nothing to lose" rhetoric is not credible. Relevant differentiation is lack of threat to state survival. In an alternate reality in which Oct 7th attacks sufficiently threatened the survival of Israel I have little doubt Gaza would be converted into a glass parking lot. There were voices in the government calling for it in this reality and of course daily voices calling for nuking Ukraine and the "west" from Russian state media.