Comment Re:Looks like... (Score 1) 112
The core issue is that children don't have much agency when it comes to their education. Entering university is often the first time they have much opportunity to make sure they get the skills they need. Problem is they get there and if they can't pass the entry exam, there isn't much other help to get them up to speed. If they get in they can take a loan or get a grant, if they don't they are a young, low skill adult who probably needs to work a lot of hours to get by.
Sure, that's a problem, but it's not one that can be solved through testing changes. Tests may not fully capture the difference between people who are behind because of circumstances and would thrive in a better environment from those who are slightly less bright, but that's an error bar, not a "these people got rock-bottom scores but would magically still do well in college" situation. It might be the difference between 1420 and 1460, but not between 1200 and 1600.
Even if you could completely eliminate the error bar, you'll still have people who get to that point and can't score well enough to succeed in college. And there will still not be anything to help them get up to speed. So better testing might help a few people right on the margins, but overall, it probably won't make much difference.
And even with the existing error bar, tests are still just as useful in determining whether to make someone take remedial classes whether the reason for them being behind was environmental or fundamental. Because ultimately, it doesn't matter why they did badly. They still need more help. And that help is either available or it isn't. The only thing reducing the error bar does is determine how likely it is that the extra help will be a good use of time, money, and resources. Throw more government money at remedial ed, and that ceases to be useful information.