Comment Re:Poor design, not impossible (Score 1) 89
How about a circle with underground rail acting as spokes on a wheel and also following the circle. Then the farthest point is the diameter of the circle. As you stated, a 170k perimeter translates to a 54km diameter. So worst case is you have to go a third of the distance and there can be more than one route. Its unrealistic that there won't be some sort of disaster over a long enough timeline. Fire/flood/tornado/terrorist attack/sandworms/etc will happen at some point. It seems like poor planning to not anticipate that and allow routes for emergency services to be blocked because there is only a single way back/forth.
You're talking 800 kph? The fastest operational train in the world is the Shanghai Maglev at 460 km/h in China.