Yes. Pretty much no-one thought SpaceX could land a rocket that couldn't hover on a barge that was bouncing around in the ocean, and they failed a bunch of times but now it's routine.
The catch exists because as you say it means no need to add delicate landing legs, and it means the booster can be placed back on the pad to be refuelled and relaunched in an hour or two. Obviously we're a long way from the point where a booster can be relaunched with minimal maintenance but that's the long-term goal.
As for price, today's flight launched Starlink satellites with bandwidth equivalent to about 10 Falcon-9 Starlink launches. So at a conservative estimate it saved them about $200,000,000 in Falcon 9 launches.. if throwing away a booster and Starship costs less than that then they're already making a per-launch operating profit.