Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Good idea for a bad situation. (Score 1) 19

To augment the review system, I think there should be an outside effort to make an AI test system that evaluates patches in a compiled kernel. The purpose would be to identify if the consequences of the patch description actually match what occurs when it's executed. I think this would be effective in reducing the amount of human review effort needed and quickly reject bad AI generated patches.

That does sound good, but it amounts to solving the halting-problem and that one is unsolvable. I do not think this task is something that AI can sufficiently approximate to be useful. You would never know how much it missed and it may also hallucinate differences that are not there or are there but behave differently.

Comment Re:Counciling a young potential CS major (Score 1) 37

It depends. When you take it seriously, enjoy it and have talent, an applied CS or IT degree makes you an expert of which there never will be enough. If you "just want a job", CS/IT is a really bad choice though.

Management is still fighting the idea that engineering works needs qualified engineers (and a good applied CS degree is effectively an engineering degree even if typically not called that), but my take is that when the current AI insanity collapses, it will be another step to the general recognition that IT is really hard when you need to do it right. And at least Europe is on the way to warranties (software warranty for end-users is already there) and liability (NIS2/KRITIS is a preliminary step) for IT products and services. And that will mean things get a lot more professional than the currently so common half-assing of things.

Hence I would anybody with the interest and talent still encourage to go into it.

Comment Re:Tech / IT really needs an trades system (Score 1) 37

It needs both: An engineering track that is proper engineering, and teaches all the advanced and hard to do stuff. Say 10% of the graduates. And a "technician" track that is more like a trade-school and teaches how to do all the well understood standard stuff right, like system administration, business coding, network administration, etc. Say 90% of the graduates.

Incidentally, for all engineering except IT, Europe has that. And ways to go from "technician" to "engineer" if you find you want that and have the talent.

Comment Re:No AI news (Score 1) 19

I don't think it's surprising that they can do that, but I still understand why a director would be upset. At the very least, I would say that such a substantial change is a violation of trust between the director and the production company. It's not like they just up-scaled the movie or added some scenes that were cut. When the director made the film, he probably didn't even consider this a possibility.

It's just another sad reminder that in the modern age the individual is nothing. The corporation is everything.

Comment Re:Go ahead, shut it down (Score 1) 96

That is a possibility. It would have been relatively easy to find out he was after underage girls and then use that to recruit him.

Trump is definitely trying his best to keep the files under wraps and he did not do that before. I think his promise to publish them was genuine. Now his fear of them getting published looks genuine as well. Which probably means that Trump did not rape any teens, at least not with the help of Epstein. But something they found in these files in the last few months has Trump deeply scared.

Comment Re:Larger language corpus needed (Score 1) 143

Interesting. I did expect pretty much the described signs of rot, but not this pronounced in a mainstream product yet. That the others still work is probably just a sign that they are more conservative on the training, i.e. more outdated on facts.

Well, if these tools are hit and miss like that, they have already become unusable because they can degrade at any time and you cannot depend on anything they produce. And no, they will not be getting better. They will only be getting worse now, except for specialist LLMs that have been trained with manually selected training data, which will be exceptionally expensive. It may still make sense for some applications where a lot of relatively uniform documents are processed, like in evaluating tax filings and the like.

Comment Re:The key words are... (Score 1) 143

The LLM can complete tedious repetitive tasks. Sure a skilled developer could also write scripts to automate many tedious tasks, but that in itself takes time.

That is the only point I sort of agree to. Within limits.

I do see that, say, prototyping the look & feel of a GUI is a task where an LLM can help. But for anything that must be done right, you are better off using that LLM as "better search" only and even that may slow you down or introduce errors.

Comment Re:Digital escorts (Score 1) 15

I expect real escorts (the hooker type) would have been more effective, because they typically have a good radar for when something feels off. They would have been about as effective on the tech side, because it is essentially impossible to monitor what something competent does on a computer keyboard. I know, I have tried.

Comment Such a surprise (Score 1) 15

The Chinese will have anything worth knowing from these MS customers now. And they will have placed countless backdoors. "Escorts" like the ones used by MS are completely worthless. I had the opportunity to observe that in person and to run some experiments a few years back (me and my boss tried to "supervise" each other, complete failure). The customer still decided to go with this flawed idea. And a few months later a developer placed a backdoor and they only noticed a few weeks later on a traffic analysis. And that developer just wanted easier access for his work, so no/low criminal energy involved.

I am sure MS knew that this scheme is just a lie and does not work. I am also sure they did not care. I would call that treason in the case at hand.

Oh, and the cleanup? They would have to throw everything away and rebuild these systems from scratch. That will not be happening as it would be a multi-year effort. and hence the Chinese will retain access to everything. I am sure the Chinese intelligence people that did this attack are still laughing at this incredible level of stupidity and sheer incapability.

Slashdot Top Deals

Adapt. Enjoy. Survive.

Working...