Comment Re:I've been warning about this for years (Score 2) 23
That's false. Beyond the artificial scarcity (by which I think you're referring to Twitter's character limit) there was also the very real problem of URL length being fundamentally broken when not truncated visually. E.g. clicking on a location in Google Maps would generate a URL 290+ characters long, and no that isn't "tracking data". And it's far from the only thing. Across many services even if you strip tracking / landing / referrer data you can still end up with insanely long URLs. Bonus points if what you're doing is intended to be typed in (e.g. from a paper advert or something similar).
Now sure this is just like the cloud. Someone else's computer in this case = someone else's link redirect, but in the grand scheme of things these things have persisted beyond Twitter's character limit for a real reason.
And you haven't stated the problem with long links.
Sure, you might want a short link if you are displaying it in a medium where someone will have to be forced to type it in - like maybe a printed sheet of paper or a poster or something. Though, you can also offer it as a QR code allowing someone to scan the link in. Sure, a QR code has a limited amount of data it can store, so a Google Maps URL is probably out of the question, but most reasonable links you might encounter on such a medium can be relatively short to type in.
Other times you may encounter a long link, but that's being sent through some electronic or digital medium so it doesn't really matter in the end since the user will just be able to click on it.
I mean, I give a Google Maps link to a friend. They're long, because they contain basically a complete mirror of what you're seeing - if you're using Street View, if what layers you have enabled, what your zoom level is and other things so a long link just happens to be the result of saving the entire context of your Maps view.
And still, the only reason for a URL shortener would be less typing if you get a link you need to manually type in. Which is a valid case, though use of QR codes and such reduce the need for them. And maybe some clever use of website redirects to make memorable URLs of y our most sought-after products.