Comment Dawkins has a rather consistent point of view (Score 1) 386
Man, I remember when Selfish Gene made its way into my hands, in the late 70's. A real "Chapman's Homer" moment for me. Led me later into a thesis on genetic algorithms. But along with that comes
While I'm not on board with Claude being in a class with humans, or cats for that matter, I think critics here might be missing a point, not about how Dawkins views LLMs so much as how he views humans. P-zombies is likely an overstatement, but don't expect him to require a 'ghost in the machine' to call Claude "conscious".
IMO, he isn't just inflating LLMs' abilities. He's coming in from a POV that humans aren't all that.