Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:The whole point of university is HI (Score 1) 102

Aka Human Intelligence. I'd expect a human to grade my work.

Agreed.

What if he uses a tool to do that? Where is the line? wc to check if you satisfied the word count requirement? A spell-checker? An AI?

Assuming that the actual grading is still done by a human and AI is just one of several tools used in the process?

Comment AI used right (Score 4, Insightful) 102

Don't understand the hate. This is actually AI being used in the right way. As an assistant. Not to replace a human, but to help with the repetitive ordinary tasks that are part of the job.

My own experience is similar. When I ask AI to generate some text for a purpose, the result is meh. But as a text critic or to get suggestions for improvements, as a proof reader, it's pretty good.

What should happen is that we don't take an AI output and just use it as-is, but use it as an input for a human who does the actual job. AI isn't magic, it's just a tool. Nobody complains that a lever enables us to excerpt more force than our muscles alone could.

Comment Re:Another Self Crashing Car! (Score 1) 154

That'd be fine for the people who live downtown, but you're forgetting about all the commuters.

That's probably a long way off, too. Right now, robotaxis are only allowed on a limited range of public roads, which doesn't include highways (and by extension, bridges and tunnels). So while they might be useful to get you from your home in a city neighborhood to downtown, but not much more than that.

(Also, I doubt anybody's really going to pay for robotaxis for a daily commute. Most people buy cars or take the train for that.)

Comment Re:Dear America... (Score 4, Insightful) 75

Come on folks. The rest of the world has had sports gambling for years and trundles along just fine.

Nope.

The USA never does something. It always overdoes everything it does. Same here.

Elsewhere in the world, sports gambling is a small side-hustle for fans who like to spice things up a bit. In the USA, everyone is always for their personal ticket into the billionaire's club, the unicorn start-up or the license to print money.

"sane" is a word that's prohibited entry into the USA and shot at the border should it try. :-)

Comment Re:local LLMs (Score 1) 32

Yes, there are some use cases where you want the LLM to essentially be a search engine on steroids. In that case, you need one that's online and vacuums up the Internet every so often. Essentially Google 2.

But for a lot of use cases a model that is occasionally updated will do just fine.

Comment local LLMs (Score 1) 32

For similar reasons (I work on projects with serious security demands) I've gone down the rabbit hole to get local LLMs working and I'm pretty happy now, but it was quite a journey.

We now have stuff like Ollama and LM Studio that can run models locally, open models that have sufficiently large rolling windows, and things like privateGPT as a glue to feed in your own documents. Or Anything LLM if you want an all-in-one solution (though in my tests it didn't quite work as well).

We're getting there. In a few years, we'll have local AI integrated into our desktops.

I personally wouldn't invest into any AI-as-a-Service companies anymore, at least not for generic models. Maybe for models custom-tailored to specific use cases. But for the generic "write a report for me" LLMs, there really isn't a need for any government to rely on cloud services anymore.

Comment yeah... nope. (Score 1) 126

With the current LLMs, noe jobs that need actual experience will be replaced anytiime soon. While the language capabilities are impressive indeed, even the best LLMs have a troubled relation with facts, truth and consistency. They'll gladly invent facts, put together totally different pieces of information of completely miss the point. For any question that I've asked an AI that requires expert knowledge where I have that knowledge (and used the AI to check or to generate more ideas) the answers I've gotten were at best junior level, and often trainee at best.

LLMs are the 21st century Wikipedia - pretty nice on common everyday topics, surprisingly knowledgable on a weird set of totally fringe things, far from something that'd be accepted in polite society.

We'll see a bunch of dumb jobs replaced by AI that so far were done by humans because computers didn't have the object recognition or ability to understand natural language. The first level call center job level.

Comment Re: Duh (Score 1) 126

ignoring the warning that they should be ready to take over at any time if the computer acts inappropriately.

Oh, and there's no such warning. When you get into the backseat of a robotaxi, it won't even start moving until everybody is wearing their seatbelts. I hardly see any passenger leaping into the front seat and grabbing the controls in a traffic incident.

Comment Re: Duh (Score 1) 126

With the exception of the occasional spectacular failure that makes the news (and refuelling/recharging stops), this is already possible. Not legal, but the technology is there.

Nah. I've rode a couple of robotaxis around the city, and while the ride is nice, it's clear we're nowhere near "get in a car and go to sleep." For one thing, the vehicles aren't even allowed on highways yet. And they require months of training on any particular urban area before they can perform reliably. I don't think there's been any training in rural or even suburban environments, which have different challenges. What you say may eventually be possible, but we're still a long way off.

Comment Re: So sad. (Score 1) 31

Different user bases. I'm a Linux fan, a couple Linux projects have my name in it. All my servers are Debian. But my notebook and desktop are Macs. Because when I need to get desktop things done, that's the platform that works best.

I waited a decade for the Linux desktop to get there and it didn't. Then I stopped waiting and started being productive.

Would I want to have a Linux desktop and application choices equal to what I have on the Mac? Absolutely. Do I expect it'll happen anytime soon? Absolutely not.

Slashdot Top Deals

And it should be the law: If you use the word `paradigm' without knowing what the dictionary says it means, you go to jail. No exceptions. -- David Jones

Working...