If I want cheap and reliable, low end Toyota or Kia.
They drive like shit.
If I want something slightly nicer, either Toyota or VW.
Toyota is not nicer than Toyota. VAG cars are unreliable heaps of electrical failures, just like a Chrysler.
If I want something high end, Audi, BMW, Mercedes.
Yeah, if you want something that will be in the shop extracting one to two thousand dollars out of your pocket every few thousand miles, by all means, buy a high-end Audi, BMW, or Mercedes.
If I want high end but lower maintenance because I can't/don't want to do it myself: Lexus.
Ah yes, Lexus, we take a Toyota and add asphalt and sell it to you for a jillion dollars. Or we make one of the best supercars ever, but we have to sell it at a loss because we can't manage cost control in anything other than shitboxes.
If I want a rust bucket that will run 200K, an american SUV/truck might do it, but it'll cost me in maintenance and gas and it won't be trouble free.
Yeah, most of those are shit, too. I'd prefer a good Toyota, or a Nissan Patrol. Toyota has fucked up all their trucks, though, the last good one was the T100. And you can't buy a Patrol in the USA.
but it'll cost me in maintenance and gas and it won't be trouble free.
You'll have less maintenance problems with an F150 than you will with any of that German shit you mentioned. There's a reason why the F-Series is the most popular vehicle in the world.
It's not the imports that are killing the american car industry, rather the fact that the american car industry is still stuck in the 60s with bandaids to deal with new efficiency requirements.
Yes, as always they would rather legislate than innovate.
Look, I believe in imports too, but they suck now as well. Renault has taken the reliability out of Nissan, the brush with Chrysler ruined the last vestiges of reliability at Mercedes, BMW is probably the best of the lot to be honest but they're not precisely known for being cheap to maintain either, high-end VAGs require massive piles of special tools (heh heh) and if you go to the dealer you will get raped. I think they have a special room for that in the Audi dealers, though, with quality German leather furniture. The kind that will hold up while you take a really good reaming.
The best cars of which I am aware all-around are the mid-nineties Subarus, Hondas and Nissans, before they got really big and heavy but after they discovered advanced engine management. The Subarus and Nissans in particular have a lot of the same Hitachi parts in common, which as it turns out were really quite good. They even shared a pretty good slush box with a lockup TC and auto rev matching. I don't fit in Hondas, so I have less to say about them. At 6'7" I have bought German cars, so I well know what that's actually like — nowhere near as rosy as you suggest.