Journal CmdrTaco's Journal: Slashdot Redesign IX: Home Stretch 76
Today's entries are largely repeats. Most (all?) of them have been posted in my journal before. Some have been revised. Some have not. I'm not planning on posting any more mockup links to jpgs. These are essentially "Finalists". The contest still is not "Closed"- We plan to take entries at least through tomorrow. Revisions to any design are welcome. If you have been exchanging emails with me, try to reply to your old emails with updates to I can keep threads together. There have been 200+ entries, and I can't keep all ya'll straight.
Michael Johnson's design has gone through a few variations, but I keep coming back to this one. I think this one needs work yet to win. I'd prefer green article titles. I want to see what he will do with that upper right hand corner. I think his left hand menu could use some fanciness. The slashbox fonts are to small for my tastes. His 'Read More' space could stand out. Abbreviated text font size is really small (and doesn't stick out well). But I think that with a few hours of work, we could make this work.
Matt Walker's entry is another sharp one. I think his logo metallic shading affect is to much- it needs to be much more subtle. Also I can't tell if he wants his background to be dark grey or dark green- there's floating green edge on the logo that doesn't work. But his menu choices are solid. His slashboxes stick out and have a lot of pop. His articles look nice.
Nate Ziarek's design features a very attractive left hand menu, and interesting slashboxes. The menu is HUGE here, and he doesn't use the upper right hand corner- but if you move the preferences up there and make the left menu a little narrower, this is an excellent entry.
Chuck
Han's entry is the only one to feature a blinking curser
Ian MacLeod's design has a LOT going for it, and one crippling bad thing: the main problem is his choice to use a light green background. It just doesn't work for me. It just feels soft. I'm not sure how I feel about the floating left column topic icons either, but I share this entry because I think his 'Rea More' graphic is great. The fading in on the left, and the curve on the right... it's a simple cool design. The drop down menus look nice for his menus. Most/All of the necessary navigational elements are here and well done. I'd like to see this with a white background in the main space instead. But it's very elegant. A great entry.
Alek Bendiken's submission is another great one. His slashboxes look cool. His header is spacious and efficient. Th gentle gradiant on the titlebars looks great. I don't care for the line between is quoted text and unquoted text- I think the line should go, and he should put a vertical line to the left of the quote and/or more space. I think the article footer is a bit bland. Unlike many entries, he paid attention to his footer. I might switch the curves from left to right... I might not. It's subtle but wonderful. This design doesn't have tags, system messages, or abbreviated articles, but it's a really great entry.
Peter Lada's entry is back once again. The issues I have with this design now are really minor. I think he uses his triangular arrow things inconsistently: I think a triangle really visiaully says 'click to expand' which works on the left hand menu- except he uses down arrows on every menu item. He has right arrow on department lines and abbreviated articles, but there's no expansion in there. I'd want to work out some minor details, but this is a great design that really looks like 'Slashdot'.
As I said before, the contest is not closed, but we are now beginning to judge on compatibility, and implementation details. Eg, how much HTML did each design change. How much 'Work' would it take us to deploy, and how well does each design work on various browsers. I'd appreciate feedback on these points especially from anyone willing to post comments here. We want our winner to look good, be compatible, and accessible, as well as lightweight.
So keep 'em coming. This is the home stretch... I want to pick a winner soon!
Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:1)
Personally I think Alek Bendiken's submission http://slashdot.macbert.com/logged_out.html [macbert.com] would make a great slashdot.
Re:Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:2)
Re:Apparently... (Score:1)
once again, my entry... not shown here yet. (Score:1)
So here it is : http://jfband.net/slash/slash4/ [jfband.net] Thanks in advance
Peter Lada's design (Score:1)
Re:Peter Lada's design (Score:1)
Re:Peter Lada's design (Score:1)
I'll add my entry here for good measure, since... (Score:1)
I've no idea whether it's simply not near interesting enough for him or something else, but I'd be interested to hear what the Slashdotters themselves think of it.
Here's a link to my entry too. Be gentle... (Score:1)
Re:I'll add my entry here for good measure, since. (Score:1)
Here's mine: http://thomas.ahle.dk/slashdot/ [thomas.ahle.dk]
Mine as well (Score:1)
http://www.optimle.com/slashdot/3/index.htm [optimle.com]
http://www.optimle.com/slashdot/2/index.htm [optimle.com]
Re:Mine as well (Score:1)
Your logo's separated color is nice, but drop the contrast between the dark and light green a whole bunch - right now it just seems to split slashdot in half, instead of accenting it.
The catch phrase could use some clean up to make it less blurry - try going for a light grey dropshadow
I like your search box, but I think you should probably round the left edge instead of go for a triangle cut - the rest of your design hinges on rounded corners, so it should fit in much mor
Re:Mine as well (Score:2)
entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:2)
Matt Walker's entry - unreadable article headlines - black on dark green. And yeah - slashboxes stand out t
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:1)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:2)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:2)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:1)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:2)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:1)
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:2)
And.. umm - where you will
Re:entries tests on galeon browser 1.3.20 (sarge) (Score:1)
Here's my design (Score:1)
My Slashdot redesign [inode.at]
please let me know what you think,
Re:Here's my design (Score:1)
The menu is far too dark for my tastes - and you'll want to sneak in a "clear: right" for the article footers
You've got a really good look going on - I love how you did the search & login, too.
Re:Here's my design (Score:1)
Re:Here's my design (Score:1)
Re:Here's my design (Score:2)
Re:Here's my design (Score:1)
My pick (Score:2)
Nate Ziarek's design.
Re:My pick (Score:1)
Font resizing (Score:2)
For mozilla firefox, pressing CTRL-+ or CTRL-- results in subject topic shaded boxes NOT to resize along with the text.
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
Did you find any outstanding issues with it on that regard? Toss me a reply and I'll see what I can do about fixing them.
Good going...(Was: Font resizing) (Score:2)
Keep it up, Ian...
My user agent is:
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.8.0.1) Gecko/20060410 Firefox/1.5.0.1
Re:Good going...(Was: Font resizing) (Score:1)
Please let me know if you see anything else I should watch for, I really do appreciate all the help from everyone.
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
On a side note, font resizing works just fine on my entry.
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
Basically, seems like a counter-intuitive behavior to me, particularly when dealing with pixel values and em values together.
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
However, it's the line height that I'd like to keep static for certain situations - for instance when you have text you want to fit into a given image. If we could resize background images via CSS, this wouldn't be a problem, and we could just set up the page (or portions thereof) to scale the way Opera does.
Sometimes the design lends itsself to holding a given line of text
Re:Font resizing (Score:1)
Z-index, images and the em-unit are all you need.
So hoping my entry will show up! =) (Score:1)
It may looks similar to the current Slashdot (I thought that's one critical point!), but look closely you will find a lot of differences to make it 'new and refreshing'. Guess Rob didn't even visited my site even though he replies my email. hmm..
Still tweaking the top menu, let me know what you think!
Thanks.
How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:1)
Re:How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:1, Troll)
Re:How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:1)
Re:How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:1)
Re:How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:2)
Doh. Well here is my entry, comments welcomed! (Score:1)
Re:Doh. Well here is my entry, comments welcomed! (Score:2)
Re:How do I know if he received the entry? (Score:2)
Have only looked on Firefox/Win (IE has font issues), but maybe someone out there might want to have a look. Focuses on layout before fluffy corners and gradients.
http://www.triplezero.com.au/production/slashdot/ [triplezero.com.au]
My Entry (Score:2)
Re:testing on opera (Score:1)
Peter Lada should win this thing (Score:1)
This is the face I want to see on Slashdot when I wake up and find that they changed the design
michael jonhnson's (Score:2)
In the end, having seen what people proposed, I would serioulsly consider sticking to the old style.
Hm. (Score:1)
--
My entry redux [20somethingdesign.com]
Re:Hm. (Score:2)
Peter Lada (Score:2)
I think the "read more" is still better off on the left as it is a much better in terms of usablility. There was one design that had "read more" on the left, and "xx of xx comments" and the catagory on the right. That was more usable while also looking more balanced. I also think that's one area that still looks a bit plane and needs to draw more attention, after all, the fo
Chuck Han's entry (Score:1)
My Submission (Score:1)
Entry - I tried this, please check it out! (Score:1)
Re:Entry - I tried this, please check it out! (Score:1)
Please review mine (Score:1)
Re:Please review mine (Score:1)
My vote (Score:1)
Collapsible story summaries (Score:1)
I would love it if regardless of which design is chosen, the story summaries could be collapsed ala Gmail. It could be login-only option to avoid compatibility issues, perhaps. Depending on your screen size you could see twenty or thirty headlines without scrolling.
I toyed with the idea of submitting a design based on this but I didn't think my puny css skills would allow me to compete with the be
What about this guy??? (Score:2)
Re:Greasemonkey script for Alex's design (Score:2)
Another Entry (Score:1)
http://jiggit.com/slashdot/newSlashdot.htm [jiggit.com]
PLEASE (Score:2)
Also - I am glad to see the new entries are taking the search box seriously. Now if only we could improve the search engine to work...
Re:PLEASE (Score:2)
When I've been offline for a few days, it's good to have nice long pages to skim through just in case Linus has ordered any beheadings or anything interesting like that that I may have missed.