
Journal pudge's Journal: Helen, Helen, Helen 36
Longtime White House reporter Helen Thomas was "snubbed" by Bush this morning, taking questions from everyone in the front row except her.
Calling him a coward, she said the two questions she wanted to ask were, "You said you didn't go in for oil or for Israel or for WMDs. so why did you go in?," and "You keep saying [FISA]'s a 1978 law, but the Constitution 200 years old. Is that out of date, too?"
I think those stupid questions speak for themselves. I'd snub her, too. She's not worth wasting the President's or people's time with.
Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:3, Informative)
The first question has been answered many, many times, and is actually lying about what Bush said: he said we did go in for WMDs. It turns out we didn't find any, but that is one of the big reasons we went in. Bush never, ever, said we did not go in because of WMDs. And the other big reason we went in was simply to get rid of a nasty guy so we can help transform the region into one more favorable to our interests (esp. one that is pro-democracy an
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
They were both C students- Bush at both institutions. Which just lowers my opinion of those institutions, actually, since it's obvious that Kerry is just an idiot who swallowed a dictionary- and Bush is just an idiot. If either had gone to OIT they would have been thrown out on academic suspension in their freshman years (I knew several who had similar viewpoints to both men who were).
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Right, because point of view is a sign of lack of intelligence. Which explains why I think you, with your Communist ideology, is not too bright.
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:1)
It'd be better to drop MH42's adhominen than to return them. I've seen you attack him twice in the last couple JEs. Your style and skill in discussion stand better without such marring.
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Besides, after his disgusing remarks about having sex with children, I've foe'd him permanently, so it won't be an issue further.
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
BS, Pudge. The war was not sold as a nation/a
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
First, I never said (in what you were quoting) that. I said this was why we went in, not how it was sold. Again, you're attacking me for things I did not say. Chill!
Second, you're wrong. Providing peace to the region through regime change was in fact a significant -- but not nearly the most significant -- part of the stated rationale for war. It was in the war resolution passed by Congress, and it was the main point
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
If it was the American people wouldn't have gone for it.
Malarkey. Those who oppose the war do so primarily because they oppose Bush, (and that primarily because they bill him as incompetent and/or imperialist) and they would have done so no matter what.
First of all, you're conflating "those who oppose the war" with "the American people." It should be obvious from all the whiners on slashdot who gripe about how the American people rubber-stamp everything Bush does that the public does not, on the wh
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Malarkey. I could just as easily say:
Of course I would be wrong.
Some people oppose the war be
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
I have discovered that I misread your previous post. When you said:
The war was not sold as a nation/ally building exercise! It is a lie to say that it was. If it was the American people wouldn't have gone for it.
... I read you as saying
The war was not sold as a nation/ally building exercise! It is a lie to say that it was. If it was the American people would have gone for it.
I found that to be completely untenable and ludicrous, and I'm sure you do, too.
Nevertheless, it prompted more interest
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
I found that to be completely untenable and ludicrous, and I'm sure you do, too.
I don't. Indeed, both before the war and since, when I expressed my reasons for supporting the war, which fall into that category, the response -- especially from people who opposed the war -- was far more positive. Granted, some of that may have been because they disbelieved in WMD, a
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Well, to clarify, I was also assuming he was conflating "the American people" with "us liberal whiners who oppose the war." Such folks tend to assume they represent a much greater percentage of the public than they do. So I was reacting to the thought that the same people who opposed the war in Afghanistan then claimed to have supported it in order to try to bolster their credibility as they opposed the war in Iraq, and the same people who seized upon recent news about North Korea and claimed they'd been
Short point (Score:2)
I take it this is from the Iraqi Body Count project? It's a huge underestimation. Firstly, it only records deaths which have two independent attributable reports. Also, it has no translators - it relies entirely on english speaking sources and a few middle eastern sources like Al Jazeera which translate across into english. By its very nature, it relies entirely on reported deaths. There is no reason to believe the number of deaths in Iraq
Re:Short point (Score:2)
Like I said, war is a meat grinder.
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
The threat posed had nothing directly to do with those
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
It wasn't any more artificial than any deadline. You're making up the notion that it was "created for urgency." I've looked at all the evidence and testimony and have seen no evidence for that.
But yes, he didn't have to go in, he could have waited longer. However, Hussein was not in compliance, and this was his M.O. for the last 12 years: as the heat c
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Correction, YOU thought he did, but there was evidence at the time that he DID NOT have WMD anymore. I love how the side
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
Actually, no, that is even less accurate than what I wrote. I was speaking for the nation, not for myself. Personally, I thought he PROBABLY had them (as I said), but I wasn't at all sure. But the nation as a whole, especially our leaders, thought he most likely had them, and that is what I meant, and I stand by it.
but there was evidence at the time that he DID NOT have WMD anymore.
Not really, no. Since the inspections were not allowed to proceed -- as 1441 said -- immediat
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
To which you have said, specifically of Ritter, "I don't believe him."
I don't recall specifically, but that sounds about right.
But you CHOSE to believe evidence, such as that of Powell, that was later shown to be completely false.
Why do you keep making things up I never said? Seriously. I never, ever, believed Powell's UN presentation showing the evidence for Iraq's WMD. I was skeptical from the moment I heard it.
Ritter, who stated there wasn't going to be any WMD found, is still beyo
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
So the source from Italy, that was show to be a complete fabrication (the names weren't even correct) has now been shown to not be a fabrication. Hmmm.... missed that one. Last I heard, we knew that it was a fabrication, we just didn't know who fabricated it and whether or not they had US ties.
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
"You keep using this word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
So Egypt's sham elections, after the war, mean they are better off? More assissinations in Syria, after the war, mean they are better off?. Iran is ramping up its nuclear program and thumbing their noses at us because they are pretty sure that we are to busy with TWO EXTENDED LAND WARS t
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
The Uranium forgery? No, what I meant is not that nothing was fabricated, but that nothing used by our government to publicly support the case for war was fabricated. The forgery was not used as any part of that justification for war.
Many people point to the 2003 State of the Union, but the "16 words" Bush had there were based on completely separate intel from th
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
You're wrong.
So Egypt's sham elections, after the war, mean they are better off? More assissinations in Syria, after the war, mean they are better off?. Iran is ramping up its nuclear program and thumbing their noses at us because they are pretty sure that we are to busy with TWO EXTENDED LAND WARS to do anything about it and they're better off? Hamas just swept elections in Palestine and they're better off?
I never said they were, a
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
"You keep using this word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
You're wrong.
So Egypt's sham elections, after the war, mean they are better off? More assissinations in Syria, after the war, mean they are better off?. Iran is ramping up its nuclear program and thumbing their noses at us because they are pretty sure that we are to busy with TWO EXTENDED LAND WARS to do anything about it and they're better off? Hamas just swept elections in Palestine and
Re:Why are these "stupid questions"? (Score:2)
I am a pacifist as well. I just don't think there is a unified anti-war crowd. When I talk to people about their opposition to the war, their answers run the gamut and they don't necessarily align themselves with any "movement." Many have a personal reason for not support
Yale grades... (Score:2)
Re:Yale grades... (Score:2)
If Bush can give unintelligent answers, (Score:2, Funny)
Re:If Bush can give unintelligent answers, (Score:2)
Forget Stupid... (Score:2)
Who is shocked he snubs her? I say next time he stand up there and tell her to go Cheney herself when she raises her hand.