What's the difference between weather, and a simulation of the weather?
Simple- the weather can get you wet. The simulation can't.
But what if I place you in a box, and let the simulation pour water on you, or blow air in your face? Is it real then?
Words- are they real, or are they artificial? Either way- an LLM produces them- they are not simulated. They are real.
If you and an LLM produce the same words, are you real, and it fake?
Are its words fake, but yours real?
You're quick to try to claim that people who reject your magical-brain hypothesis can't tell the difference, but the fact is- you can't even define the difference in any way that passes scientific muster. When you know, you know, amirite?
The problem here is that you're trying to cram all that it is to be human into one word that it simply does not fit into.
My 21 year old niece is intelligent enough to understand this- why aren't you? Are you fake, and she real?