Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:KDE vs GNOMElets (Score 2) 141

Altough I use GNOME I think Gnome is more "bizarre" nowadays than KDE since they departed from the traditional desktop metaphore, but most new users I've showed the interface somehow get things done on Gnome.

I don't know however if it's packager fault but I always found KDE software less reliable than Gnome's (tried it on Debian, Slackware, and Fedora), specially after KDE4. Even with the controversy, most of what Gnome software offers to users work, for example Evolution. Last time I tried KDE (I think it was KDE 4 something, one of the latests) it's PIM suite would be awkward and never actually got it to run for some reason it also depended on MySQL, which I find quite bizarre. Outside of PIM many of KDE options would malfunction (sometimes bringing the whole application down) or not work at all. What's the point of promising the world to the user if all it's going to fall apart after a couple of clicks? I'd rather pop up a terminal and do stuff from there than having to figure out why the GUI of something doesn't work as expected.

As for the bloat, coming from a Gnome user seems hypocritical. Gnome sits idle on fedora at 1Gb of memory, so if KDE is bloated, Gnome it's also a pig. If you compare both with MATE or XFCE, they are both bloated.

yet there's what, 3? 4? GNOME forks going, most of which were sparked by GNOME being such a clusterf*** to build.

This is innacurate, most Gnome forks were born from disagreements with the overall divergence with the traditional desktop paradigm.

Comment Re:Umh, so like, what's it do? (Score 1) 176

When you have to market your greatest release with updated emoji you know you got nothing.

No, I just answered your questions. That's why questions are made for, for answers. I found it funny how someone can be so angry at other people working on something.

Comment Re:Can't Log Out? (Score 2) 176

, and they don't seem interested in fixing the horrible mess they have created. In fact their current goal seems to be to remove as many options and alternative settings as possible.

Or perhaps they don't see it as an horrible mess and just disregard disrespectful people who come trying to impose their vision on them.

Contributing is just that, just contributing, not pretending becoming the boss of a project at day one because you know better than everybody involved in it.

Comment Re:Umh, so like, what's it do? (Score 2) 176

I've dropped Debian because of Gnome 3

You've dropped a Linux distribution that lets you choose the desktop at installation because you didn't like the desktop they ticked by default? You're clearly not the sharpest tool in the shed.

Comment Re:Umh, so like, what's it do? (Score 1) 176

I mean, for people that want to code, or browse or watch a film, maybe do some multitasking why choose GNOME over anything else?

Because it's easier to set up, doesn't get in the way, can be used easily with a keyboard.

Is it easy to use and customise? Is it fast? Is it stable? Does it need a fuckton of dependencies and forces unnecessary shit on users?

- Yes is easy to use, my in-law uses it when she uses my brother's computer and finds it really intuitive.

- If you have good hardware is fast, otherwise you have a plethora of other DEs to use, including the previous version of GNOME now known as Mate.

- Pretty stable on both my desktop and laptop. In fact it has the best support for multiple monitors that I've seen on Linux so far.

- Well define unnecessary, if it's needed by the desktop to run, then it's not unnecessary. Yes you can go minimal with other WM, but you also lose quite a lot of features that Gnome brings: easy software installation, power management, fast file/program/document search, calendar integration and more. If you don't feel like you need any of that, well use another thing, or use Gnome and disable those features, it's easily doable from their control panel.

System search?! Emoji?? - what the fuck are these people doing?

- The whole desktop focus around searching and it does a pretty good job at it, you basically press the super key, type something and open up the program/file you want, or write the mail for any contact you have. If you don't like that, well, don't use it, nobody is forcing you.

- Emoji is quite frivolous but very popular nowadays, not everything has to be "super serious" and if someone contributed that to the project, who am I to criticize.

- Well they are developing a popular Linux DE, they could also be ranting about other people's work on the internet.

Once upon a time GNOME was clean, fast and simply didnt get in the way of doing shit. KDE was a slower but was very shiny. These days they both suck.

Then use Mate which is literally the GNOME2 desktop you miss or KDE, or install a shiny theme, at this point I don't even know what you want.

If I wanted a horrifically bloated "flat" interface with seven layers of buried shit menus I'd just use Windows 10.

- Gnome interface is hardly flat, there are flat themes, the default one is not. I'm suspecting you're just full of shit and never even used the damn thing.

- It seems you're looking for an excuse, just go and use Windows 10, nobody cares.

Slashdot Top Deals

"The medium is the message." -- Marshall McLuhan

Working...