Comment Re:money (Score 1) 91
U.S. defaultism...
U.S. defaultism...
The U.S. is somewhat lagging behind, because right now, it's some kind of anti-virtue signalling to go fossil despite the advantages of electric. This fad will ebb.
There is only one situation where hydrogen could make sense: if you can use surplus electric energy in your hydrogen generating plant, so you can get the energy basically for free. But that means that you have quite the discontinuous process, which sounds not very efficient.
A second problem with fuel cells is the way they are spec'd out. To save on cost, they are combined with a traction battery and cover only about 30% of the total power output of the car, acting as a range extender for the traction battery rather than the direct power source for the motor. This makes sense if you are moving mainly in flat terrain and in stop-and-go traffic, where you only need short bursts of high power output. But if you are living in mountainous terrain (as I do), they don't fit. Just the mechanical energy necessary to lift a car about 1000 or 2000 feet will exceed the traction battery's energy storage, and the time to travel up that ramp is too short for the fuel cell to recharge the battery. It means that somewhere around 1000 feet, your battery runs empty, and now your car has only 30% of power left to pull it upwards. Europe with its many mountain ranges, from the Pyrenees over the Massif Central via the Alps to the Balkan Mountains is not the right terrain for fuel cell cars, as they are quite challenged to get across.
The town of Innsbruck, where I live, was testing a fuel cell powered bus two years ago on the line 590 (Innsbruck - Neustift im Stubai). With a height difference of about 1500 feet between the bus stops Innsbruck Süd and Schönberg, the bus was losing power for about a third of the distance, having only fuel cells for about 75 kW of the 225 kW of installed electrical power.
In general, migrating birds fly at altitudes of 3000 feet and more above ground, far out of the reach of windmills, and hunting birds fly at the level of their prey. For most birds, this means insects flying at less than 100 feet, out of the reach of windmill blades.
Within one year, from April 2023 to Jan 2024, market prices per kWh dropped 50%, from about $200/kWh to $95/kWh. And this is no fluke powered by one-time events. A lot of progress in the last few years was indeed technological and came not from new chemistry. The Cell-to-Pack and Cell-to-Blade processes, which allow very large but still stable cells made the LFP cell viable for automotive application and Sodium cells at least for stationary use. Doting the LFP with Maganese, creating LMFP cell types can add another 20% of capacity within the same technology. Anodefree cells (where the anode will form itself with the first charge) will allow for even cheaper production. Organic cathodes might boost the capacity of sodium cells up to 600 Wh per kg, but are currently very expensive compared to iron phosphate - but if the organic compounds are cheaper to made, they will become competitive.
You won't find many of the new ideas in your everyday cell. But that's not because the ideas are not viable. It's because the current cell types are progressing themselves so fast, that they are still the most marketable option. But whenever the development slows down too much on them, the other options are ready to shine.
Your body contains about a kilogram of phosphorus. Your bones, teeth, and DNA are made of phosphorus.
And still, White Phosphorus is deadly in doses of less than 1 ppm. Enumerating elements is completely meaningless when talking about toxicity. What matters is the substance which contains the elements. And two chemically closely related substances can be harmless and absolutely toxic. Botulinum toxin, often called Botox for short, is deadly in doses above 2 ppt (or about 150 nanograms for a grown adult), and all it contains are the very same amino acids, which make up about 15% of your body weight.
Copper is necessary for human life.
Same silly argument.
Interchangeable parts won't.