Comment: Re:Expensive, ultimately disposable infrastructure (Score 1) 216
Ultracapacitors will never reach the power density of batteries. The main reason is that the battery can lay down thousands of layers of a chemically changed state at the change of state voltage.
The capacitor can lay down a single layer, at first, when the second layer is built, a space charge analog effect occurs, sine the 2 layers have the same charge polarity and repel each other.
Capacitors are made to have a very large area, far larger than batteries, and they can discharge this rapidly and can be repeatedly charged and discharged, since there is no wear mechanism. With capacitors, the charge is a function of voltage, as you draw charge, the capacitor voltage drops. Batteries are flat in voltage profile until the battery substance has deplated,m it then falls to zero.
The mechanical analog is a spring, which flexes and the force declines, the hydraulic analog is a dam -which empties