Comment Can you be compelled to disclose which finger? (Score 1) 328
You cannot withhold your finger print.
You can withhold something which is in your mind. E.g. a pin.
Since only one (or two?) of your fingers unlock your phone. Your knowledge of the finger print possibly qualifies as secret knowledge. And multiple attempts will ultimately prevent use of finger prints.
The police would not (I think) be able to force you to disclose. They would be free to instruct you to use a specific finger and hope that it unlocks. But if it fails I don't think they would have any recourse.
So don't use your thumbs or index fingers. Which would be their starting point.