Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 1) 1081

Self evidently the answer was to give him his books.

How do you get that? the quote is poking fun at the infantile punishment metered out for punishments sake onto Lector. It was not aimed at providing closure to some victim, it was not to discourage future crimes by either him or others. It existed simply to hurt Lector because they they wanted to hurt him. He was providing the only two ethical solutions. I think Dr. Lector himself would argue that given the option between making him as comfortable as possible while attempting to prevent further crimes vs simply ending the threat to society for once and for all, the latter was the wiser of the two ethical solutions. And all this is forgetting that there is no real human being who could be locked in solitary confinement, with books or no, in perpetuity and have any kind of life. Euthanasia will always be kinder.

Comment If that were true ... (Score 1) 667

your and you're would be synonyms by now. That is problem with such an absolute. Yes languages change natural with use because much of what makes up a language is arbitrary. But much also is not arbitrary, it is a certain way because otherwise it would be impossible to communicate effectively. It does not matter how many millions of people regularly confuse your for you're it will never become correct because it is necessary for the language to have those words remain distinct.

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 1) 1081

And it depends a whole lot of how much the people trust the legal system. A lot of countries have a populous that trusts its legal system, and at least some of that is from the executions it used to do. When some young girl get murdered or raped, the natural thing that happens in any culture is people will go out and kill people they suspect of doing it. Even in modern times in first world countries sometimes whole villages get massacred because some resident is suspected to be the rapist of some sweet young girl. Unless restrained by their government. In many countries their is enough respect of the law that that is all it takes. But that is not so in America. There is continual civil unrest and for some reason the government is not willing to address it. There are some crimes it does not matter if you catch the criminal, just that you publicly punish someone. There are just some crimes that free people will not get over. The rape of murder of a woman. Or, in America, the death of a black person. Arguably, not that this falls within those bounds, if America has executed some banker for he financial crisis. If they had executed Zimmerman. Etc. There would be more trust of the system and then the system would be given more leeway to dispense actual justice. But there has to be trust in the ruling of courts before that can happen.

Comment Good (Score 1, Insightful) 172

Cloning would completely destroy the sport. The whole fcking point is the slow and laborious process of breeding the prefect horse. Every one unique. It is not about stealing a clipping of the winner horses hair and creating a copy, or generically engineering an even better race horse. Considering that both the sports and the breeding would be destroyed by the ability to just create whatever you want in the lab, how else are they to respond?

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 2) 1081

It should not be about that. If someone cannot be rehabilitated. If they must forever be confined for our societies safety, they should be killed on compassionate grounds. Requiring someone to be punished in perpetuity like some sort of hell on earth is barbaric.

“We live in a primitive time—don’t we, Will?—neither savage nor wise. Half measures are the curse of it. Any rational society would either kill me or give me my books.”

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 5, Interesting) 1081

Killing is not for punishment. No one who says that legal system is about punishment knows what they are talking about. Legals systems are about civil obedience. When the victims, the populous, cry out for blood you need to give it to them or face civil unrest. It is about making an example out of people to discourage other lawbreaking.

Comment Re:Unfair comparison (Score 1) 447

This is grossly inaccurate. Placebos have been proven to not only have extreme psychological effects like curing pain, but also sometimes extreme physiological effects. For example, placebos have proven to be a good alternative to steroids for strength enhancement. Curing infections. There are any number of stories of people walking again or regaining their eyesight when given a placebo. There is pretty much absolutely nothing that is not positively influenced by placebos.

Comment Re:This ex-Swatch guy doesn't have a clue (Score 1) 389

Considering Tesla actually is marketed more as a high end car than some save the whales green peace car I don't agree with your analogy. Tesla either is, or is in a great position to quickly become a direct competitor to those all levels of rich "car" guy cars. Yes they cannot win over the retro-revamed 1964 chevy muscle car guys, but the guy the goes out to buy a NEW Porsche is looking at Teslas. Apple is not and never could become a direct competitor to either those $30 cheap give give me the correct time watches, or those 1-2 hundred cheap look at this gold thing strapped to my wrist watches, or those multiple thousand dollar mechanical pieces of art.

Comment A News Agency is making Computers? (Score 1) 106

What? Shouldn't we get competent people within their area of expertise do that? Isn't the BBS owned by the British government? Don't they have to explain their expenses and stay within their charter? AKA We give you X million a year to produce good British programming, not run amusement parts or build condominiums.

Slashdot Top Deals

Mystics always hope that science will some day overtake them. -- Booth Tarkington

Working...