Comment Re:Don't we already have conventions? (Score 1) 166
Dilemma of determinism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D...
I'm going to say that any reasonable definition of Free Will that is incompatible with determinism is a definition for a thing that doesn't exist, regardless of how deterministic or non-deterministic the environment is.
I will however accept that reasonable definitions for Free Will can be made that are compatible with determinism (and non-determinism). I feel that the difference between Compatibilism and Incompatibilism is, at that point, simply a matter of the semantics around "free will", which has never had a simple, universal, well-posed definition.