Comment Re:Topic in this case sounds like streaming.... (Score 1) 213
you made your argument well
yes, the american way of thinking seems to be to desire everyone be a well rounded scholar in a wide range of topics
as an american, this idealistic to an extreme
the usa regularly fails legions of young students. so we're nowhere near the grandiose goal you have pegged as desirable. but, in actuality, is highly improbable except for a tiny fraction of students. such that you're probably failing more students in worse ways than finland or china
perhaps the usa should learn from finland and china, and stop trying to turn everyone into a renaissance man, and teach a fucking skill. yes, some people can and should become great scholars. but others would benefit much greater if you taught them how to just fix a fucking car, how to install electrical wiring, or how an HVAC unit works
you refer to the notion of a flexible society. but a flexible nimble tiny subset has always been the norm, and always will be. the rest get set in their ways, always were set in their ways, and always will be set in their ways, and never had, have, or want to have, the ability to be more flexible
you refer to jobs being made redundant. i don't believe plumber, carpenter, or surveyor have gone out of style since the days of the roman empire, and i don't see robots mixing and hauling concrete at the work site more cheaply any time soon
a skill someone someone can use to fund stable secure lower middle to middle class lives, rather than being english majors asking "do you want fries with that?" seems like a much more laudable and practical goal than what you have outlined
maybe then the son or daughter of the ably and stably employed machinist, raised in a modest, secure household, can become a great poet