My education in the wilds of Alaska was not a typical American education.
NPR is running a series on American High Schools. So far the most scathing bit is on American High Schools failing to teach logical and critical thinking skills. As an Engineer, I use critical thinking skills daily. I isolate problems, formulate hypothesis, test them and decide on which hypothesis is correct or not.
Each time through this cycle I get closer to a solution to my assigned problem. Each trial gets me closer to the truth. Without this skill I would be unable to function. If I have ever had difficulty working with anyone it has been over the ability or inability to accept this method as a realistic means of working.
If you say something is better, you'd better be able to prove it. That's my official stance. In adult life all of my conflicts have been over this one issue... proof. Can you prove that claim? Is your proof sound?
Many times I've worked with people who find those two charges offensive. They are offended that I would question a claim or proof... that I would test another professional's assertions. This is sometimes read as arrogance. It is not. I expect my same assertions to be tested in the same light. I do not expect to make a claim and have that claim merely accepted because I said so. The experiment, the test, the proof are what separate engineering and science from religion, faith, and magic.
To me the idea that these concept is missing from modern American schools explains a great many things. For one thing, I do not have a typical "American" education. My education was heavily supplimented by my father. He was a field biologist and taught me from the age of ten how to collect samples, observe, and make notes like our naturalist fore-runners. By Junior High he had taught me how to have a control group in my experiments. He also taught me how to isolate an experimental variable.
He also taught me to think critically. To question and verify claims. He taught me how to use a lab and lab equipment. All this I learned from my father. He was the one that taught me to maintain mental rigor.
My mother taught me faith and religion and to love learning. She is the one who taught me art and meditation. She gave me the tools to know awe.
My education in the wilds of Alaska was not a typical American education. My parents educated me. It seems that the modern American is not educated by their parents. It seems to me that they are dropped off at school and forgotten.
If there is a problem with modern American education it is in the communication of culture. It's the teaching of rigor and awe that's missing. How do we fix this? How can we replace the role of parents? Should we do it?