Comment Re:Different government levels hinder smart growth (Score 1) 244
As a result, there is very little coordination, and we end up with sprawl because of it.
No, we end up with sprawl because living the American dream includes a home with a yard and not high density housing. And even when planners are forced to create HDH to reduce or slow sprawl, Americans would rather continue to spread out to get their piece of the dream than live in a 'Pass the Sugar' neighborhood or HDH communities.
The biggest problem with all of this is that instead of building transit infrastructure which makes sense, we try to retrofit half-broken models into areas where it will not work. BRT, supposedly LRT on rubber (we heard this in the 1950s - 1970s; oh how history repeats itself), was going to be the savior to the communities here South of Mpls/StP. What we ended up with are widened roads, a lot of construction, and the eventuality that express buses taking 35 minutes to get downtown will be eliminated so we can take up to 1.5 hours to do the same trip on BRT (they claim this won't happen but after spending 100+ million on the project, they will want it to be used and it won't be until they force it to be).
There are so many competing interests and opinions in our country that stating simply that 'building new roads is easier' is not entirely true. It sucks but we get to deal with it.
Yay for progress.