Comment Re:Some details about the 3D printer (Score 1) 129
Crossing the ocean was a dangerous and hostile ordeal. On the other hand, once across the ocean, conditions were far more hospitable. Humans can generally live off the land if they have to, and build some sort of civilization.
Now, consider any place in the solar system outside Earth. There is no breathable atmosphere. Temperatures are way outside what is survivable. In most cases, there's no available water. In other words, there has to be complex life support apparatus, and this cannot be allowed to fail. If the remaining humans are to build a new civilization, they not only have to keep their life support going indefinitely, they've got to be able to expand it. They've got to be able to maintain and expand power plants of significant size. They have to be able to manufacture each and every part required. They have to be able to mine or otherwise acquire each and every resource needed.
Consider a permanent self-sustaining Martian colony. It needs pressurization, so people can breathe. It needs to be able to replenish air. It needs to be able to produce food, and recycle water. It needs to be able to maintain a livable temperature. This implies some high tech and complicated machines. It also implies a sizable source of power. It probably has to be tens of thousands of people, to allow for necessary specialization.
This might well happen eventually. It can't happen right now, and I don't see that sending a few people to Mars about now is going to help. Once we have all the tech we need lined up, and realistic plans of how to get it there, sending a few people to make preparations will make a lot of sense.