Comment Re:Intelligent life (Score 1) 334
SGU was the best contemporary space-based sci-fi tv series with the kind of science fiction that had never been depicted before
You don't think that's overselling it a bit? I mean, the initial premise is that they're on a spaceship that's millions of years old...and been flying that whole time...across multiple galaxies...which they managed to teleport to by exploding a planet.
And then once they get on the ship, they spend the vast majority of screen time having human drama about how Rush is a huge sociopath and everyone hates each other. I think there was also occasionally some actual sci fi thrown in...
I'm not sure what you think SGU did so uniquely that SG-1 and SGA didn't. Maybe when they initially showed up and then spent the first four episodes just trying to keep the ship from falling apart, I guess...but that was because the premise was so ridiculous that nobody would believe it otherwise.