Comment Re:They've got a lot of catching up to do... (Score 1) 431
I don't think that saying the US is literate necessarily means that one must be saying that the US education system is working.
As a homeschooling parent, I have looked at a lot of different ways of educating my children. One of the ways that I have seen (although rejected for my family) is radical 'Unschoooling'. The premise of this method is that no one teaches children anything. Anything the child needs or wants to learn, they will seek out themselves. While I don't think this produces the best results, talking with Unschooling parents revielded an interesting result. Literally 100% of the children over the age of about 12 were literate. The could read, write, had reasonable vocabularies, and had no problem structuring their sentences.
Keep in mind that this isn't a self selected group of kids who's parents spent extra time educating them. These are kids who parents left the kids to figure out their education on their own. Only being their to answer questions that the child initiated.
Obviously not everyone becomes literate when left in a vacuum. So, what is the explination? I have thought pretty hard on this, as it is an unexpected and facinating situation. The best theory I have come up with is that it is hard to actually be illiterate in large parts of the US. I am not saying that it is hard being illiterate, which it most certainly is. I am saying that one needs to actually put effort into not becoming literate, or it will happen by accident.
I know it sounds crazy, but consider that Karmashock is correct that there are groups who actively shun education. Parents who will abuse their children if the children shows any interest in become educated. I have witnessed this first hand. It is sad but real. So, if we discount families and groups who are actually putting effort into being illiterate, we end up with situations where kids learn to read and write the same way that you learn what color your neighbors house is. You happen to see it so much that eventually, you just know it. Drive past a giant yellow M in front of a 'M'c Donalds, and eventually the kid picks up that M makes an M sound.
As a homeschooling parent, I have looked at a lot of different ways of educating my children. One of the ways that I have seen (although rejected for my family) is radical 'Unschoooling'. The premise of this method is that no one teaches children anything. Anything the child needs or wants to learn, they will seek out themselves. While I don't think this produces the best results, talking with Unschooling parents revielded an interesting result. Literally 100% of the children over the age of about 12 were literate. The could read, write, had reasonable vocabularies, and had no problem structuring their sentences.
Keep in mind that this isn't a self selected group of kids who's parents spent extra time educating them. These are kids who parents left the kids to figure out their education on their own. Only being their to answer questions that the child initiated.
Obviously not everyone becomes literate when left in a vacuum. So, what is the explination? I have thought pretty hard on this, as it is an unexpected and facinating situation. The best theory I have come up with is that it is hard to actually be illiterate in large parts of the US. I am not saying that it is hard being illiterate, which it most certainly is. I am saying that one needs to actually put effort into not becoming literate, or it will happen by accident.
I know it sounds crazy, but consider that Karmashock is correct that there are groups who actively shun education. Parents who will abuse their children if the children shows any interest in become educated. I have witnessed this first hand. It is sad but real. So, if we discount families and groups who are actually putting effort into being illiterate, we end up with situations where kids learn to read and write the same way that you learn what color your neighbors house is. You happen to see it so much that eventually, you just know it. Drive past a giant yellow M in front of a 'M'c Donalds, and eventually the kid picks up that M makes an M sound.