Comment Re:If only :) (Score 1) 337
So the GDP is "the market value of all the final goods and services newly produced on domestic soil during a given time period".
So if i buy from you a service and i pay you with a dollar, then that dollar gets accounted in the GDP. (BTW this would be accounted under "consumption" (C). If you sell the same service to a business it's called investment (I), if you sell it to the government is called government expense (G), and finally if you sell it overseas it's called net export (NX)).
If i give the same dollar to you as a gift then no, it's not part of the GDP. If i decide that digging hole is a service and you dig a hole for me and i pay you a dollar it does go in the GDP. And this is true whether i am the government, a business, a consumer, or a foreign entity.
So if I am the government and you dig a hole for me and i pay you then it goes into the GDP directly. When you spend part of that dollar on other things that part goes in the GDP as well. So the multiplier of digging holes cannot be less than one (if i am doing the math right, in this simple model is 1/(1-Cy) with Cy = dC/dY between 0 and 1).
If I the government give you money for free then it's called a tax rebate, you will spend part of that dollar, and (only) that part goes in the GDP.
So in that simple aggregate model the multiplier is Cy/(1-Cy), which is less then one if Cy is less than 0.5, basically depending if on average people spend that dollar right away or not.
Now, here is the important point, if you are not rich and are "budget constrained", chances are that you WILL spend almost the whole dollar right away on a car, a beer, or whatever is of value to you. So if i give 10$ to the poorest half of the population and they spend them right away on whatever is of value to them, then essentially those 10$ go directly in the GDP and if you consider that the liquor stores and car shops in turn spend part of that money then the multiplier is probably still greater than one.
Actually this has been a good exercise for me to think about this concepts in order to explain them. Thanks