Comment Re:i.e. I'm so desperate to deny reality... (Score 1) 329
You are correct - there are issues with Nikolov's ideas (I was actually referencing Jelbring, but some of the ideas are similar), specifically, now can the equilibrium temperature of a black body be different with an atmosphere without GHGs? I don't think it can, but that doesn't mean that the tiny amount of CO2 is going to make up all the difference, and I think it's a good starting point to describe why the "radiative forcing" theory is clearly wrong.
There is a better discussion at (Oh Nos! DENIERS site) Watt's blog, and he has the same problem with those theories himself.