Comment Re:Another day, another codec. (Score 1) 86
Agreed, Xiph wanted to create a clean codec (which is still the problem with VP8) but you are right: they just didn't balance the engineering and comp-sci effectively. They could have shot for incremental progress, releasing something new every couple of years. Instead, they had a few underpaid open-source enthusiasts working on it for a decade.
That being said, when it came to negotiations, it was REALLY important that Vorbis was around to give everyone an idea that open source codecs were at least viable. Had Google just seen a standard proposal, they wouldn't have invested $100m in buying up On2!