Comment Re:Well duh (Score 1) 457
I used to think anonymity was part of the problem, but I haven't seen improvement when some forums have switched to real names, so I now no longer think that really helps. My local paper switched to Facebook as its commenting platform, with comments posted under real names, and the comment section is still as terrible as before.
I think real names do help, but only some. I think you can divide the population into three groups:
1. The people who will be civil, at least most of the time, regardless of anonymity.
2. The people who will be civil if they have to attach a name they care about (which may be a pseudonym).
3. The people who just don't care. Most, if not all, of these are asses in real life, too. We all know some.
I think the majority of people fall into group 1. Group 2 is a minority. Group 3 is a tiny minority... but on the Internet the relevant population of even a moderate-size site is enormous, so a tiny minority can do enormous damage.