Submission + - YouTube Thinks "I Have a Dream" Is Lounge Music (vice.com)
Daniel_Stuckey writes: For decades the "I Have a Dream" speech has been a rallying cry for civil rights everywhere. It's also been the centerpiece in a quiet, long and unfortunate copyright war, caught between those who might argue it belongs in the public domain and those who insist that it's in the private ownership of the King family. In the process, videos of the speech have disappeared from YouTube, under a copyright controlled by the music publisher EMI, and a system charged with robotically policing copyright on all of YouTube's videos.
In the latest chapter in the speech's copyright morass, that system, Content ID, has decided that at least some of the rights to the speech—and the profits it generates from each view—belong to a company called GR8 AL Music. At some point in the past few months, Content ID has decided that the video contains a lounge song titled "Our Dream," from an album called Lounge Cocktails, Vol.1 (Delicious Grooves for Café Bar and Hotel Suites).
Algorithms work in mysterious ways. The video doesn't contain that song. In this peculiar case, "I Have a Dream" has likely been confused with the song because the song itself contains an excerpt of King's speech.
In the latest chapter in the speech's copyright morass, that system, Content ID, has decided that at least some of the rights to the speech—and the profits it generates from each view—belong to a company called GR8 AL Music. At some point in the past few months, Content ID has decided that the video contains a lounge song titled "Our Dream," from an album called Lounge Cocktails, Vol.1 (Delicious Grooves for Café Bar and Hotel Suites).
Algorithms work in mysterious ways. The video doesn't contain that song. In this peculiar case, "I Have a Dream" has likely been confused with the song because the song itself contains an excerpt of King's speech.