Dueling Network Neutrality Commentary on NPR

cube farmer writes Wednesday National Public Radio featured a commentary by telecom representative Scott Cleland in opposition to Network Neutrality legislation. Thursday Craig Newmark, the Craig behind craigslist, countered that Network Neutrality is essential for consumers. Who made the stronger case?

That's a tough one!

[7macaw]

>Who made the stronger case?

If you thought reading TFA was hard, how about listening to TFR broadcast two days ago!

Not having heard the arguments

[bigpat]

...I would have to say Craig made the strongest case.

Countered?

[IDontAgreeWithYou]

One guy says that net neutrality is bad. Another guy counters(?) that net neutrality is bad. I thought I was getting an argument, not two different statements of the same opinion.

Re:Lies from Scott Cleland

[fnord_uk]

Out of curiosity, who thinks that Microsoft should pay for the traffic caused by millions of people downloading security patches for Windows?

Re:Craig. And Tim Berners-Lee. And Vint Cerf. And.

[Etyenne]

Who do you think is right?

<sarcasm>Only the market can be right !</sarcasm>

Loaded question?

[bcattwoo]

Who made the stronger case?

Hmmm...I predict a lot of healthy discussion and changed minds on this one.

Re:Countered?

[Jeremi]

I thought I was getting an argument, not two different statements of the same opinion.

No, no, this is abuse. Arguments are down the hall and to the left.

Stupid git.