Comment Why RISC-V? (Score 1) 37
I like what Purism is doing; but I'm a little curious about the emphasis on RISC-V. Yes, I know that the ISA is available under more liberal terms than ARM or x86 and gets more attention than SPARC or openPOWER; but but that's more of a thing for people doing ISA implementations or chip designs. Aside from a few FPGA projects RISC-V implementations are generally proprietary(not that people really notice because very few are in the position to just call up the fab and ask them to start a few wafers); and both RISC-V and ARM have(or at least can have, some parts don't play nice with them) open toolchains.
I certainly wouldn't be against a RISC-V part if it seemed like the better option; but "you could do an implementation of the ISA without any royalty payments!" seems like a basically irrelevant feature vs. ensuring that whoever actually did the implementation didn't include anything that makes a properly open design difficult or impossible(along the lines of the Intel ME, or some 'trustzone' core that never actually leaves the vendor's control or the like).
I can imagine that some RISC-V vendors may be better in that area(if nothing else because they have less accrued cruft in some weird ARM blob that they've been slowly moving from core to core over the last decade); but I don't see how, assuming two parts equally free of weird little vendor enclaves, the user of a proprietary implementation of an open ISA is freeer than the user of a proprietary implementation of a proprietary ISA.
I certainly wouldn't be against a RISC-V part if it seemed like the better option; but "you could do an implementation of the ISA without any royalty payments!" seems like a basically irrelevant feature vs. ensuring that whoever actually did the implementation didn't include anything that makes a properly open design difficult or impossible(along the lines of the Intel ME, or some 'trustzone' core that never actually leaves the vendor's control or the like).
I can imagine that some RISC-V vendors may be better in that area(if nothing else because they have less accrued cruft in some weird ARM blob that they've been slowly moving from core to core over the last decade); but I don't see how, assuming two parts equally free of weird little vendor enclaves, the user of a proprietary implementation of an open ISA is freeer than the user of a proprietary implementation of a proprietary ISA.