Comment A trainwreck (Score 1) 241
As I was reading this article, I saw the trainwreck happening before I reached the end of the story. The age of the child wasn't part of the description but yes... taking pictures of the groin area of your kid, even well-intended is child porn.
At least in the eyes of the service providers.
Playing devil's advocate here, they (the service provider) do not and cannot have the context. Imagine if a child predator could argue that their sick pictures are for diagnostic purposes.
Imagine that the only thing you have to go on is the picture. Is it appropriate to take this picture, to have it on your phone? How would you decide? Should you allow a discourse? Should it be possible to argue that the picture is not child pornography?
I don't know the answer to many of these questions, but. Google saw a problem, Google reported the problem to the authorities and the authorities said "nothing to see here"
At the very least, Google should be taking into account the answer from the police and reinstate the accounts. Google should also not unilaterally revoke all means of contact.
Remove the offending content, by all means. Block user from deleting content, yes, but restore the account after the police clears them.
At least in the eyes of the service providers.
Playing devil's advocate here, they (the service provider) do not and cannot have the context. Imagine if a child predator could argue that their sick pictures are for diagnostic purposes.
Imagine that the only thing you have to go on is the picture. Is it appropriate to take this picture, to have it on your phone? How would you decide? Should you allow a discourse? Should it be possible to argue that the picture is not child pornography?
I don't know the answer to many of these questions, but. Google saw a problem, Google reported the problem to the authorities and the authorities said "nothing to see here"
At the very least, Google should be taking into account the answer from the police and reinstate the accounts. Google should also not unilaterally revoke all means of contact.
Remove the offending content, by all means. Block user from deleting content, yes, but restore the account after the police clears them.