I think it's a great idea. It was a technically reasonable solution to sharing the costs of hosting and serving content when the web was small. It got run over by spam and trolls and warez eventually but we've learned a lot about content moderation and filtering in the last 25 years.
The main issue is that companies feel they can't monetize their own content if they have no way to control distribution servers, but that should not be a consideration for open source provided it's the kind of open source that is willing to be free to use by everyone.
So they should willingly contribute to the public good by wholly paying for not just the expansion they want themselves but also extra.
Many of them will eventually, by going out of business. That will cause demand destruction. In the meantime they are like the smelly neighbour who showed up at the party, and everyone just has to hold their nose.
The US Navy has been acting as pirates in international waters. That is a fact. People have been kidnapped, cities on the shore have been bombed, civilian ships have been threatened, damaged, and sunk, people have been murdered. What part of this isn't piracy?
And the comment wasn't unrelated to the thread: Bread and circuses. Roman Empire. Predatory behaviours. Every empire that runs low on resources inevitably thinks to plunder from the neighbours.
The more they over-think the plumbing the easier it is to stop up the drain.