Comment Re:Amazing if it works (Score 1) 111
TLDR: Agreed, if it is taken directly. But indirectly the strategic leaders must take the broader population into account
Leaders in democracies are quite limited by laws and parliaments. They cannot go to war only on their own whim. Quite a lot of persons need to be on-board i.e. agree that the war has sense for them as well
As for as dictatorships, dictators have more decision power themselves. But they still need to keep their key supporters happy (at least the lead of internal state security, the lead of internal revenue and the lead of army). And these key supporters need to keep their supporters happy too (i.e. take opinions of more people into account). Anyway, if the dictator can think strategically then he will consider the overall economic consequences. Otherwise the war only hastens his demise. And their long term outlook is not very good anyway. About 20% of dictators are imprisoned or killed.
The point is that it is unlikely a dictator cannot think strategically. If he wants to survive then he must. And since he survived so far then he very likely does think strategically. It is a brutal long term fight to become a dictator.
If it looks to us that a leader went to a stupid war then it very likely only means the leader had bad information about the military power of his country or the military power of the opponent. And as we already know
The leader's key supporters either had bad information too or they plotted for leader's demise.
The war likely does not mean that the leader did not consider the economy of the war. He just made a honest mistake. Shit happens. More likely in dictatorship than in a democracy since more people are involved in a democracy.
E.g. one could think that Putin did not take economy of the war with Ukraine into account and that he behaved irrationally (e.g. on some nonsense like Russian World political concept). I do not think it is true. He just believed that the war will be successful and cheap. He likely believed it will take only a few weeks and Ukraine will give up and become a satellite state of Russia like Belarus is. He likely believed Europe and USA will not do anything significant as they did not do after Crimea. The broad Russian population definitely thought it will be an easy win for Russia. Even western intelligence though so. It was overwhelmingly popular at its start in Russia. Russians believed they can extract enough benefits from Ukraine to bear the small costs of the "special military operation". We do not know the numbers but currently it does not look like the war was a good idea - even if Russia prevails at the end.