Comment Re:I'll say the same thing i was saying 20 years a (Score 1) 124
Even in a "pure" p2p setting a rogue or buggy peer can affect negatively the whole network (or at least it's peers and their peers). Gnutella G1 isn't pure p2p, though. It elects "ultrapeer" nodes, leaf nodes etc. it's said that Shareaza is a buggy G1 ultrapeer, wasting other nodes' bandwidth and CPU cycles. Also, in general Shareaza's G1 support is based on a very old Gnutella version, containing obsolete features and bugs that have been long ago fixed in other G1 clients. As a result, some G1 users and clients outright ban Shareaza, refusing to communicate with it.
Anecdotally, I have personally tested Shareaza's G1 support and have found that it finds way fewer files and downloads slower than true G1 clients like Phex and Limewire (when limited to G1, of course, because Shareaza supports other networks too).
Of course, if such whistleblower videos are found only on G1, the community should take measures to make them available on G2/Shareaza, the eDonkey2000/Kad/eMule network etc. so as many people as possible could use their favorite p2p software to download it.