Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Please absolutely -slate- this...please (Score 2) 36

I absolutely do those things. I have a lot of various bits of smart home tech and have used Siri for years with it. It's never been stellar but it's been completely serviceable. The non-AI Siri still is. The AI one...it's just astonishing bad. It told me it couldn't set timers on a watch. It started playing music when I told it to turn on the lights. It didn't understand I have a shortcut invoked with "open charge port" and started doing some web AI-based nonsense about it instead of running the shortcut. It doesn't honour the "show text on-screen" setting, meaning I can't check what message it's about to send after I dictate. I have example after example of failure, which is why I turned it all off and went back to ye olde which works...mediumly.

Now on macOS, I've left Siri AI on. That's because I have a completely different use case for my Mac than I do my iOS stuff - on the Mac I'm doing more heavy lifting-type work. I'm more likely to want something that can create me a quick bash script, or tell me a quick run down of the oscillators of two analogue synths, or, or...whatever. I don't use voice with my Mac, so I don't issue it commands in the same way I do to my phone or watch. For that kind of more analytical use case, Siri AI is holding its own. But in the general purpose universe of controlling things, i.e. precisely the thing this new HomeView device is primarily intended for, Siri AI has been an abject failure for me and I've switched it all off.

Comment Please absolutely -slate- this...please (Score 5, Informative) 36

I have been utterly baffled reading mainstream reviewer support for the new Siri AI. It is, not to put too fine a point on it, utter garbage. I've been reading reviewers on the various Mac/iOS sites saying it found an airport ticket receipt in their mail so it could work out what time to go and pick up their Aunt from her annual trip to...you get the idea, obscure nonsense that no-one actually does. Meanwhile, the thing people actually do use it for - "Hey Siri, set a five minute timer", "Hey Siri, turn on living room lights"...terrible, terrible stuff. Claiming it can't set timers because it doesn't have the timer app - on the Apple Watch. Have a quick browse of Reddit's /r/Siri and weep tears of hilarity, disbelief and despair.

It is unambiguously terrible. Flaming awful. I've disabled it on all my iOS devices. It is exactly what I'd expect from AI - it can handle links for elaboration and stitching together things that can be found by ingesting lots of text, but it is appalling at handling.g actual imperative commands.

I don't know how it's programmed of course, but if it had a layer of old fashioned speech recognition and then grammar parser against known commands before it then handed things off to the fuzzy world of AI, it would be far far better. I want it to have a syntax parser that always recognises commands like "turn on ", where if it hears "turn on" it then searches its known list of HomeKit devices. I want a support page that lists this invariant known grammar that it absolutely will recognise, and I want that layer before it tries passing it to anything resembling an AI. I want a glorified yacc-style grammar that's absolutely and completely unambiguous. After it's gone through that layer, sure - pass it up to whatever fuzzy text machine you like. But understand the basics first - imperative is not a dirty word, you don't have to try to infer everything all the time.

It's absolutely and completely terrible. And I want prominent voices saying so, both in the general tech world, in the Apple world of reviewers, and in the non-tech general audience consumer advice world. I want it slated, humiliated and known as the joke it absolutely is. Because nothing, nothing seems to be getting through to these AI acolytes that AI isn't the answer to everything. Imperative, known syntax commands please. I want you to be embarrassed to turn up to work saying you're a Siri engineer. I want the absolute magnitude of the complete god awfulness you have produced to hit you day in, day out until someone actually properly grasps the problem, throws out the corporate orthodoxy and gets back to some real programming that produces predictable results.

In case you're not quite picking up on my nuance and subtle messaging here - it's garbage. It's trash. It's a dumpster fire. It's....it's....bah!

Comment Lessons from the physical world - 1831 bridge fail (Score 4, Informative) 77

This is eerily similar to the marching soldiers' bridge collapse - Broughton Bridge in 1831, often misattributed to Napoleon but happened after his reign.

Lessons weren't learned 180 years later either, for the Milllennium Suspension Bridge, which I happened to work next to at the time and watched the construction and failure unfold. People tend to walk in sync. When things happen in sync, a resonant pattern emerges. It's true for people crossing bridges. It's true for people synchronising machines to exact clocks and nice rounded-off times as well.

Comment Re:Laundry folding? (Score 1) 57

For me the robotics vs laundry issue is ironing, not folding. It might be different in the US but I don't do a lot of laundry folding here in the UK - I just hang them up in the wardrobe or put them in drawers. Towels and spare sheets maybe? Not much.

But an ironing robot - yes, that one I would interested in. It needn't be some humanoid thing that stands by an ironing board and moves a traditional steam iron up and down - could be a static cupboard for all I care. There was a spate of announcements about 10 years ago but nothing came of them, only these blow-up air pressure ones that don't really work at all on work-style clothing. Ironing robots please.

Comment Re:Rumors of my demise... (Score 1) 125

I mean, they literally show the use case for it on some of their the videos. It's not a general purpose one by any means, but this one is an actual Pro box, not a "I'm a consumer and just want the name Pro on my device" box.

The current use case is music production. Logic Pro. I have an Akai MPC Gen 2, with a touch screen for moving around the DAW and manipulating the virtual instruments. Logic Pro with the same level of interactivity would be fantastic, and no the iPad version doesn't cut it. I'm actually very interested in it for this specific reason.

Price? Well, I paid around £4k for my Intel 4Tb beast in 2019 to store all the sample-based instrument libraries I have. It's not a "let's buy this to look cool at the coffee shop" machine, although I'm sure some people will. I'm actually very interested in it for a serious step up in the way music production works.

Comment To paraphrase Ghostbusters (Score 5, Interesting) 93

"I'll tell you the experience. It's pissing me off!"

I log in to read, but I regularly open threads by right-clicking and open in a different tab. Since I mostly use private browsing (Safari or Firefox) to stop advert tracking, this means that one tab is logged in but most of the ones I open to read later are not logged in. So now that pattern is dead? Then there's the "site:reddit.com" searches I do on topics that I just need an answer for rather than ever wanting to participate in. Again, same pattern - I use private browsing and I usually right click and open multiple tabs on several likely looking search results before then starting to read each tab to see if anything useful turned up. That pattern gone as well?

The summary touches on this next bit too - I'm wondering what will happen when I send a link to someone else, some of whom don't have and will likely never have Reddit accounts. Are they now simply unable to see it? Even Facebook isn't that harsh, and it's the perfect example too. I do not have nor will I ever have a Facebook account, but I'm sent the odd link now and again which I do open and look at without needing an account. A world where Facebook is more open than Reddit is just...odd.

I get their dilemma, but this seems a bit too far to me.

Comment Re:What is "the internet" (Score 1) 199

I have account number 13,802 here, which I've never been able to persuade the admins to recover for me. Notice how there's no activity on it. That's because when I created it and saw that user number come up I thought "huh - no point in carrying on here then, how could anyone possible read or make sense of anything with nearly fourteen thousand people on it?".

Since then, the chorus on various sites has become rather larger than merely fourteen thousand. The background noise is incredible. I'm amazed any signal gets through at all vs the constant noise to be honest.

Comment Re:Solar is not enough (Score 1) 102

It's not either/or though - if you're generating more than you're using, then you can redirect that back into the battery (or sell it back to the grid). I have limited winter experience at the moment, but the battery is fully topped up during the day while still powering the house from solar. That said, the darker nights/evenings right now means you kick into battery power earlier, so for me for example at roughly the same lattitude as London, the battery is drained by about 9pm.

It's interesting to watch and fun too if you're in to that kind of thing. Which, quite clearly, I am.

Comment Re:Solar is not enough (Score 1) 102

That's increasingly true here too (UK). I'm on an EV-focused tariff which guarantees me up to 6 hours cheap EV charging per day, and in addition there are lower, cheaper overnight rates for the electricity.

What's been noticeable recently is that these periods are now tending to be different. I've been driving EVs for eight years and on roughly the same tariff (the 6 hour cap is new), and usually the "cheap EV charging" and "overnight low rates" coincided. Now however, I've noticed that if I plug in the EV during the day it pretty much starts charging instantly and you're right - I could say that's 100% around lunchtime. My usage means I can't really take advantage of that much since I commute in the day and plug in in the evenings, but it's still a noticeable pattern for the days that I am either working from home or its a weekend.

Slashdot Top Deals

All programmers are playwrights and all computers are lousy actors.

Working...