Comment Re: Please absolutely -slate- this...please (Score 2) 36
I absolutely do those things. I have a lot of various bits of smart home tech and have used Siri for years with it. It's never been stellar but it's been completely serviceable. The non-AI Siri still is. The AI one...it's just astonishing bad. It told me it couldn't set timers on a watch. It started playing music when I told it to turn on the lights. It didn't understand I have a shortcut invoked with "open charge port" and started doing some web AI-based nonsense about it instead of running the shortcut. It doesn't honour the "show text on-screen" setting, meaning I can't check what message it's about to send after I dictate. I have example after example of failure, which is why I turned it all off and went back to ye olde which works...mediumly.
Now on macOS, I've left Siri AI on. That's because I have a completely different use case for my Mac than I do my iOS stuff - on the Mac I'm doing more heavy lifting-type work. I'm more likely to want something that can create me a quick bash script, or tell me a quick run down of the oscillators of two analogue synths, or, or...whatever. I don't use voice with my Mac, so I don't issue it commands in the same way I do to my phone or watch. For that kind of more analytical use case, Siri AI is holding its own. But in the general purpose universe of controlling things, i.e. precisely the thing this new HomeView device is primarily intended for, Siri AI has been an abject failure for me and I've switched it all off.
Now on macOS, I've left Siri AI on. That's because I have a completely different use case for my Mac than I do my iOS stuff - on the Mac I'm doing more heavy lifting-type work. I'm more likely to want something that can create me a quick bash script, or tell me a quick run down of the oscillators of two analogue synths, or, or...whatever. I don't use voice with my Mac, so I don't issue it commands in the same way I do to my phone or watch. For that kind of more analytical use case, Siri AI is holding its own. But in the general purpose universe of controlling things, i.e. precisely the thing this new HomeView device is primarily intended for, Siri AI has been an abject failure for me and I've switched it all off.