Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Odd morality (Score 1) 139

Really? So if a dev goes out with a team lead the TL should be fired?

Possibly. The problem is if you create a work environment where people are reasonably led to believe that they have to have sex with the boss in order to get ahead. That can be bad for business, and in many jurisdictions can lead to expensive lawsuits. Thus we have corporate policies to avoid or manage this situation.
The moral angle may be important to some, but it's not the reason for the policy.

Comment Re: they will keep selling them (Score 1) 285

Ask ChatGPT, it will give you the data from the same source you're quoting. The bracket starts around $20. Only highly skilled workers pass the $40,

Sigh. Asking ChatGPT to "say something about a topic" is not the same as a citation of facts.

What I quoted was government economic data for the broad category of "Motor vehicles manufacturing" which has a definition in national statistics. The $40 number was *not* a subcategory for highly skilled workers. You fail to cite anything to support your claim that it is.

Nothing you're saying supports, logically or in fact, the absurd statement that employment in a factory equals slavery.

The hardness of work doesn't make a slave, the degree of freedom they have over their own life does.

You're changing your definition of slavery. Nothing in your earlier post addressed it in this way. You quoted false statistics about employment and wages, which you have now further failed to support when questioned directly.

In other words you're just making things up, and failing to connect things logically. I don't know if you're a troll or just in a poor state, but it doesn't matter to me. People making stuff up are a dime a dozen on this platform. I don't have the time for it. Good day to you.

Comment Re: they will keep selling them (Score 1) 285

Slaves workning a factory, too, don't they? US federal minimum wage is at 7-odd dollars unchanged since 1990s,

Literally 15 seconds with google gave me these labor statistics from https://www.bls.gov/iag/tgs/ia...
$40/hr + benefits is not really slave labor, especially with the cost of living in places that tend to have auto factories. Your citation of a $7 federal minimum wage (which is of course higher in local jurisdictions) is hardly relevant.

Average hourly earnings (of production and nonsupervisory workers)
Motor vehicles and parts manufacturing
2025 12 month change sep 2025 - sep 2026
$32.80 $1.86
Motor vehicles manufacturing
$39.49

an average factory worker's net wage is aboht the same as a month's rent

Citation needed. Average rent in Detroit (across all levels of housing) is $1200 according to Zillow. That's 30 hours pre-tax at the rate cited above.

no retiremennt, sick time, holiday or maternity mandated (and typically not available).

Citation needed. The big 3 automakers are unionized.

Homelesaness made illegal in large parts of the country, yet aboht 50% of the honeless habe jobs.

Citations and spell checking needed.

incarcerated people usually are forced to work

I was not aware that incarcerated people are building cars, or that they make up a substantial portion of the working population. Feel free to cite some credible data.

It's true there are a lot of incarcerated people. I'm sure you're aware that despotic nations, to which you are comparing the US, do not necessarily provide accurate incarceration statistics.

At this point, a slave has it better,

This is so incredibly disrespectful of the many people past and present who have been impacted by slavery, that I'm not going to dignify it with any further response.

Comment Re:Pluto is a planet (Score 1) 70

It turns out that the IAU calls the orbit "cleared" even if there is small stuff and trojans about. Much like I can call my bedroom floor "cleared" even though there is dog hair still about. The local Marital Union has declared that this meets the definition. However we have agreed that there may be no trojans on a "clean" floor.

Comment Re:Pluto is a planet (Score 1) 70

N.B.: By the strict definition of "planet" used by the IAU, even Jupiter wouldn't really qualify

Sure it does. Jupiter is, per IAU definitions, a planet.

because it hasn't cleared it's orbit. There's a lot of small stuff and, of course, the trojans.

That's true. I suggest the issue you're having with definition here is: what is the definition of "cleared it's [sic] orbit"? Here is some info about what the IAU has said about that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

Comment sue them all, I guess (Score 2) 125

Because if it wasn't for Flock we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.

Because if it wasn't for police we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.
Because if it wasn't for cameras we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.
Because if it wasn't for cars we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.
Because if it wasn't for computers we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.
Because if it wasn't for electromagnetism we wouldn't be here in the first place, and this whole nightmare... would not have kicked off.

Comment Re: Makes me wonder (Score 1) 128

If you steal ideas, the Math community will be even harsher on you

I can agree that stealing ideas is pretty universally considered bad. I can't agree that neglecting to fully disclose all the diverse inputs and sources of ideas that go into a mathematical paper will necessarily be interpreted by the community as evidence of theft. It has not been my experience as a member of the mathematics community.

Especially when the paper is proof of a counterexample, as in TFA. You ignored my example of Fermat's Last Theorem, maybe because it was fictional? Here's a related paper from an actual mathematics journal disproving Euler's conjecture for k=5. https://www.ams.org/journals/b... It looks to be about 40 words long.

It does say "a direct search yielded" (easy today but I wonder how much compute time that took, in 1966.) Is your assertion that if they had left those words out, we should treat their paper with suspicion?

You are just trying to confuse the issue with nonsense.

This seems a bit accusatory and needlessly combative so I'm going to tune you out.

Comment Re:Sounds about right (Score 1) 128

Your comment was about soundness not credit.

But yes TFA is about credit, so did you mean to say

any kind of scientific publication has been required for a long, long time to cite all inputs to be regarded as [legitimately yours]. The result may stand, but the claim that it is your result will not unless the citations are there and complete.

I think I'd have to disagree with this too, in mathematics. For scientific publications that rely on empirical data collection and experimentation I can see how citing the sources of data and the established experimental methods you relied on would be important.

Comment Re: Makes me wonder (Score 1) 128

It is stealing if you do not cite all of them in your publication. The standards for scientific misconduct are VERY clear: You are not allowed to hide your sources.

Math != empirical scientific research.

Fermat's last theorem was open for a long long time. Someone eventually proved it, but what if it had turned out to be false? What if a grade school kid had run a bunch of random numbers on her computer and by pure luck found an a,b,c so that a^3+b^3=c^3? She wouldn't have to cite anything. She could just publish the three numbers in a journal (they'd be falling over each other to publish it) and be famous. Trivial to verify. Mathematics would have been advanced by this event, even though the counterexample itself and the method for discovering it wouldn't have been deep or insightful in any way.

OpenAI is asserting that an important, long-open conjecture is false. The way they found their counterexample may or may not be interesting to mathematicians. Even so, it may be very interesting to AI researchers. LLMs, for all their limitations, may wind up being very useful at finding counterexamples to open conjectures, through a sort of semi-optimized brute force. We shall see.

Comment Re:Sounds about right (Score 1) 128

Also note that any kind of scientific publication has been required for a long, long time to cite all inputs to be regarded as sound

I don't know about scientific publication, but there is no need whatsoever in mathematics to cite all inputs to be regarded as sound. It just needs to be verifiable from known facts. If what you've discovered is a counterexample, as is the case here, then it is often *much* simpler to verify that it is indeed a counterexample than it is to talk about how you discovered it. Disclosure of the "how" is interesting but not required. It could be outright plagiarism and still be mathematically "sound."

Comment Re:"Trade issue" my ass (Score 1) 229

When dealing with trump it is was always going to be a lose-lose situation.

I'm not in the business of shilling for Trump. That said, I always want this to be what the opposite side has to say about my negotiator(s).

Why? "lose-lose" means your side is losing too. Many of us would want our negotiators to establish "wins" for us, and would not be specifically opposed to the "opposite side" also gaining something potentially. Often that's the best win in a transaction.

As for referring to Canada as the "opposite side," that's a very transactional view of things and I guess it's the position you'd have to take if you're going to shill for Trump. The Trump administration is not renowned for being strategic in their negotiations or their communications. But strategically the fact is that Canada is a ally, a friendly border, and an economic partner, not to mention the social, political, and cultural connection. Shitting on them and creating "lose-lose" situations is hardly laudable. It's not good business or politics.

Comment Re:will the former OSS employee be protected from (Score 2) 67

Sure, I'll pay you $200 annually to map out and implement a DR plan with 3-2-1 backups and a contracted third party on the hook to go through the runbook when the earthquake hits.

It's not practical for us to try to solution here but a contingency backup of 50 TB of digital assets might be as simple as making a second copy and dumping it onto media in a box somewhere. It's an archive not a live system. Or whatever. Point is, it's not that hard to have *something* beyond just blind faith that a vendor will keep their end of the bargain.

Other non-technical contingency plans would include making sure the contracts have provisions for this common-enough scenario so you don't have to litigate in court to get your stuff back from Iron Mountain.

It's impossible to plan for every obscure scenario but this is not an obscure scenario. Business partners go out of business all the time.

Here's another hint: When was the last time you contributed to your local PBS station's pledge drive?

Just this spring. Anything for my Professor T.

If you're suggesting that the mismanagement of this contract and related contingency is just due to lack of resources, well, maybe that contributed, we don't know. If so, it would be fair to take that into account when deciding whether to fire the managers. It doesn't change my point though, which is that this type of planning is standard management activity, and you generally can blame managers when they have zero contingency plans on the loss of such an important asset.

Comment Re:will the former OSS employee be protected from (Score 2, Insightful) 67

You can't blame Nine PBS for their data handling partner to go belly up

Actually we can and we do. You need to plan for contingencies. If you've got an asset that's vital for your business and want to store it with someone else, you need to figure out up front what you're going to do if they disappear, or damage the asset, etc. If the Nine PBS management didn't do this then they should be canned.

Similarly, if you put your money in a bank, you need to know what will happen if that bank fails. In many places, there is government-backed insurance for exactly that. If that didn't exist, we'd all need to manage our money differently. (And likely in a way that is not generally advantageous to the economy. That's why the government provides the insurance.)

This is just victim blaming.

The point isn't victim blaming. Rather, I strongly recommend that you take a lesson from this incident if you're ever going to be in charge of anything important.

Slashdot Top Deals

Can't open /usr/games/lib/fortunes.dat.

Working...