Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:"Can never prove correlation is causation" (Score 1, Interesting) 172

Which, indeed, they did not: 'Although you can never prove that correlation is equal to causation, certainly the most plausible explanation is that [the tremors] are related to the gas injection.'

In fact, they took the very valid point that coincidence (not even correlation, as CrimsonAvenger correctly notes that other seemingly similar cases do not display the same coincidence) does not imply causation, and then decided to breeze past it and declare that "certainly" that causation is the "most plausible explanation". In other words, coincidence --> correlation --> causation. I don't dispute that observation could be used to prove this causation, but where are those observations?

Comment More data analytics, not more sensor (Score 2) 14

IMHO, just throwing more sensors at a city does not make it smarter. What city infrastructures are really missing now is smart data analytics to make sense of raw sensor data. Such analytical technology is only beginning to emerge (for example, in the space I know best, my own company TaKaDu which provides software to analyse the data from a rather sparse array of sensors in local water distribution networks, and monitor for faults). Without that, you end up with ranks of analysts and engineers staring at columns of numbers which go up and down for a long list of reasons, hunting for the few meaningful patterns or anomalies, with predictably limited results. "More data" or even "more mixing of different data" is just the first stepping stone.

On a related note, an interesting industry collaboration on these topics (again, within the water industry) is SWAN -- Smart Water Networks Forum, focused on the wide variety of data systems which go into managing water networks, one of the more hidden, but most critical, city infrastructures.

Comment Really, AI on a smartphone is the best solution? (Score 2, Interesting) 245

If I already have my smartphone with me, or indeed any phone with camera, and I can take pictures of my skin condition (or whatever), and write or talk about it, perhaps I could SEND the photos and comments to a REAL LIVE doctor, even one who works more than a few hours drive away, but within phone coverage, and get his NATURAL INTELLIGENCE comments, instructions, etc. over the phone? Is AI going to be better and cheaper than human doctors any time soon? And assuming it does get that way, why does it need to run on my smartphone? Through the magic that is the interweb (of which I believe smartphones are a part), would it not be easier to send the data to a slightly more powerful SERVER, and get my AI GP's advice from there? Slapping "AI" and "smartphone" on a problem does not make for a brilliant futuristic solution.
Privacy

Israel's Supreme Court Says Yes To Internet Anonymity 198

jonklinger writes "The Israeli Supreme Court ruled this week that there is no civil procedure to reveal the identity of users behind an IP address, and that until such procedure shall be legislated, all internet postings, even tortious, may remain anonymous. The 69-page decision acknowledges the right to privacy and makes internet anonymity de facto a constitutional right in Israel. Justice Rivlin noted that revealing a person behind an IP address is 'an attempt to harness, prior to a legal proceeding, the justice system and a third party in order to conduct an inquiry which will lead to the revealing of a person committing a tort so that a civil suit could be filed against him.'"
The Internet

Submission + - Why the CAPTCHA approach is doomed (blogspot.com)

TechnoBabble Pro writes: "The CAPTCHA idea sounds simple: prevent bots from massively abusing a website (e.g. to get many email or social network accounts, and send spam), by giving users a test which is easy for humans, but impossible for computers. Is there really such a thing as a well-balanced CAPTCHA, easy on human eyes, but tough on bots? TechnoBabble Pro has a piece on 3 CAPTCHA gotchas which show why any puzzle which isn't a nuisance to legitimate users, won't be much hindrance to abusers, either. It looks like we need a different approach to stop the bots."

Slashdot Top Deals

Hotels are tired of getting ripped off. I checked into a hotel and they had towels from my house. -- Mark Guido

Working...