Is it evil, or merely Grade-A Capitalism?
You create a product in America that is two-tiered, with certain features exclusive to those who pay for Premium features. Then you find that consumers are able to steal from you by sidestepping said features. Which of course in turn deters current Premium members from continuing to pay, so they cancel their membership and choose a sidestepping alternative instead. Which directly impacts your revenue and ability to survive.
IF YouTube were a small to medium sized female/minority/veteran-owned business on the brink of bankruptcy and these kinds of thefts were the direct reason for facing that business-destroying challenge, would you suddenly find sympathy and support? Don't bullshit and be honest.
The standard retort of "Because they can afford it" is an excuse that only works for so long. With business expenses like that, it doesn't take long for an entity to have actual solvency problems, and not some shit staged for clicks and likes. No matter how bored humans are during an AI-triggered Depression, I seriously doubt YouTube doom scrolling from The Unemployables is going to sell enough ad revenue that ignorantly targets Unemployables who can't afford to buy a fucking thing pushed in those ads. Because Permanent Unemployment.
Food. Clothing. Shelter. YouTube is in the business of selling NONE of the shit that actually matters in a Depression. The wake-up call, is coming. Especially for every "influencer" who will soon find out the actual real-life value of a YouTube channel in a Depressed world that doesn't find narcissism holding any value at all.
No. I'm not defending YouTube. I'm too pissed off at the corruption that allowed Too Big To Fail entities like YouTube to claim that defense eventually. Yes. I promise they will pull that shit. No. You won't be given an option, taxpayer peasant. That's the real problem.