Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: What we made ourselves .... (Score 1) 63

It is about the journey not the destination. The point of the competition was to teach valuable skills that the kids would have picked up while making the game

Using AI effectively is *without a question* a valuable skill for a developer to pick up nowadays.

IMHO manual coding also still is, but I wonder for how long. There is no question in my mind manual coding is going the way of the Dodo, the only question is how fast.

Comment Re:What we made ourselves .... (Score 2) 63

If you're asking AI "Make an anime themed roguelike in Godot. It should have the following..." - I don't care how much elaborate world-building you do after those ellipses, "you" aren't making anything.

Well, let's say that you "code" the game the traditional way. You are still using Godot, which you likely did not make yourself... Can you really say "I made this"? Furthermore, let's say you liked Breath of the Wild a lot and decide to base your game on it, but create your own characters, story etc... can you say "I made this"?

Even with traditional coding and before AI we often stood on a mountain of existing work that made our job much easier if not at all possible comparing from making it from scratch from the ground up, either through existing technologies, ideas, art etc...

AI gives even more chances to "stand on a mountain of existing work" given its ability to re-create it on-demand, but it doesn't mean a good developer can't drive the tool instead of having the tool drive everyting and even with your suggested prompt it can be a starting point or prototype that gets developed into something else, just like dozens of successful, original games started as basically Breath of the Wild clones.

Basically AI makes easier to create just copies, but also makes it easier to take these copies and turn them into an original game if driven that way.

Comment Re:I'm in the EU (Score 1) 192

and I don't back this action.

France will not back this action either.

What passed is an amendment to the 2027 national budget bill, but it was in a late, very poorly attended session and against the explicit objections of the government. The vote was with 35 deputies present whereas the full chamber has 577 deputies.

TL;DR: it will almost assuredly not survive further reviews of the 2027 national budget bill before the bill will become law.

Comment Re:Utah (Score 2) 50

You seem to be confusing Christianity with Catholic doctrine. Nice try, but you do not get to define Christianity.

The Nicene Creed is accepted far more broadly than only by the Catholic Church and that's how "Christianity" has been defined for centuries.

Now people can decide to define their own terms, but it's fact that the vast majority of Christian denominations agree to the fundamental doctrine that one needs to believe to be "Christian" and Mormonism believes in something different.

Comment Re:Utah (Score 1) 50

The theological underpinnings of LDS includes both the Old and New Testaments of the Bible. The bulk of LDS theology is the same as the rest of Christianity.

From the point of view of the rest of Christianity you need to at least agree with the Nicene Creed to be Christian.

That the bulk of the LDS theology is the same is irrelevant if they disagree with that fundamental creed, which they openly do. They have a different understanding of the nature of God compared to what the Nicene Creed professes.

Comment Re:Utah (Score 3, Informative) 50

Who decides what Christianity requires? The pope?

Traditional Christianity is based on the adherence to the Nicene Creed.

Nearly all Christian denominations, including Catholic, Orthodox, and most Protestant churches (e.g., Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists, Continental Reformed, Presbyterians, Congregationalists and Baptists), regard the Nicene Creed as a foundational and authoritative statement of faith.

So Mormonism believes in Christ in a way that is not compatible with the Nicene Creed. This makes them "not Christian" from a doctrinal point of view in the eyes of all those Christian denominations that do hold the Nicene Creed as foundational.

Comment Re:Utah (Score 3, Informative) 50

In other words, YOU decided you are the gatekeeper for who is and isn't a Christian who believes in Christ, and because they don't worship the way YOU do, they must not be Christian. Most people that you declare as "non-Christian" just shake their heads and walk away from your ignorance.

Traditional Christianity is based on some core doctrinal beliefs that have been identified in Scripture and have been formalized in what became the Nicene Creed. One of the core doctrines in the Nicene Creed is the Trinity: one God in three persons, eternal and uncreated.

Mormonism's teaching is that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are three separate beings, that the Father has a body of flesh and bones and that humans can progress to become gods themselves. This is not compatible with the doctrine of the Nicene Creed.

That's the reason traditional Christianity does not consider Mormonism as part of Christianity from a doctrinal's point of view.

Comment Re: Induced demand (Score 1) 149

A bike lane can't possibly have a larger capacity than a car lane. It only takes a little bit of thought to see why. You must be comparing the typical car lane with the theoretical max capacity of the bike lane.

I am talking typical usage. In typical usage a car lane is very inefficient since cars have on average very low occupancy, are large and require significant safe distances. In comparison, bike lanes are much more efficient since bikes are much smaller and can safely travel closer together.

This is true for a single car lane vs. a single bike lane, but consider that for the space occupied by a car lane you can easily have 2 bike lanes, so a comparison of capacity per area is even more in favour of bike lanes.

Comment Re: Induced demand (Score 3, Insightful) 149

I personally donâ(TM)t want to drive. I quite dislike driving. I prefer a short walking commute, and when that's not practical I prefer mass transit. But for many people, driving is the only practical way to simultaneously accomplish several aspects of the life they want to live, including being housed in a very low-density area, working in a high density area, commuting without significant walking sections, etc. Those desires are not a matter of planning.

IMHO they actually are. As example, the typical American residential low-density suburb is the result of significant planning and the way it's structured is a fundamental reason for car reliance. Other countries have made different planning decisions and that leads to less reliance on cars.

I currently don't need a car: I can do everything I need with either mass transit or a bicycle, but if I were transplanted in a typical American suburb I will almost guaranteed switch to a car. People will do what is a combination of most affordable and most convenient and how cities, residential areas, commuting, shopping is planned has a huge impact on what is most affordable and convenient.

Also it's important to keep in mind that once the planning allows for alternatives to the car that are affordable and convenient, car users also benefit immensely from that. The reason is that a road has a relatively small capacity. A bike lane occupies a fraction of the space of a car lane and has 5-10 times the capacity. Every person that decides for an alternative to the car is one car less on the road which benefits every other car user.

Comment Re: Fully local my arse. (Score 3, Informative) 90

Of course an AI agent has never lied or misused available resources, like your neighbors default password wifi ? I can think of many uses for a truly isolated local AI instance. In a book I read as a teenager, the hero made an AI called Oscar. I've been hooked since then. Long live "the far being Retzglaran"

I think you are missing the point. I have queried the AI completely offline, meaning without any connection to the internet. The AI was able to respond without issues even in that situation, meaning that it does effectively work completely offline.

Comment Re: Fully local my arse. (Score 4, Informative) 90

I'm never going to trust a model-provided flag, mate. Full firewall, completely cut off from the internet is the only way. Sadly, many models won't work at all when isolated.

Just ran a quick test and e.g. ollama launch claude --model qwen3-coder-next works offline without issue, as long as you already have the model downloaded locally.

> do you need internet access to function?

No, I don't need internet access to function. I can work offline with:

- Reading/writing files on your local system
- Running local commands (git, npm, builds, tests, etc.)
- Using tools like LSP for code navigation
- Managing tasks and workflows
- Creating artifacts and editing notebooks

I do have access to some online capabilities when they're useful (web search, fetching URLs, etc.), but they're optional — I can work perfectly well without internet access as long as you have the files and tools you need locally.

Comment Re:slop vs security (Score 1) 50

The problem is no longer about reports being bad, but currently about reports being duplicate. You write a bug, ten people's AIs find the bug and report it. You need to read ten reports about the bug and decide that nine are duplicates.

An AI can easily decide that, at least as first step triage. It's one of the activities where it can be exceptionally good.

Slashdot Top Deals

If God had not given us sticky tape, it would have been necessary to invent it.

Working...