Comment Re:Not helpful (Score 1) 274
> That's...kind of important? Even water can be deadly, if you drink too much of it in too short a period of time
There's an important subtlety lost here. Water doesn't cause cancer, and water has no deleterious side effects until a certain threshold has been reached, and thankfully that threshold is large.
For Aspartame, that threshold is zero. Any consumption of Aspartame starts accruing deleterious effects, namely that it is carcinogenic.
Drinking a small amount of water contributes x = 0 chance of developing cancer, consuming aspartame contributes x > 0 chance of developing cancer.
People who say "the dose makes the poison" are both right and wrong, because they're forgetting that some substances have a critical threshold before they start having any deleterious side effects.