And it is like this with e.g. music software. If I 'buy a license' for Reaper (good IMO), you get a file that unlocks it without online activation. If I 'buy a license' for Bitwig, and Bitwig's activation servers stop playing ball, I lose my access to software I've paid for. Arguably if I buy something with iLok protection, it is up to me to protect the physical device if my licenses are stored on it. But that sucks too. But in general, if something requires online activation, and the activation servers are deactivated, you lose what you paid for (as happened with earlier version of Propellerhead Reason). In a sense, some licenses are like food which goes off after a 'best before date', or like hardware which has a warranty period and, after that warranty period, it may cease to function. Or perhaps a DVD where the disc goes bad after a while and becomes unreadable. In a sense, subscriptions are the most honest thing out there (and I am no fan of the modern fad for subscription software), where if you stop paying, you lose the capability of running stuff that you may depend on. At least with a subscription they make clear that if you stop paying your annual or monthly fee, you lose access.