Comment Re:"Is the ban on the police using it a good thing (Score 1) 70
What is the logic there? How do you get from "police have misused it" to "police should be banned from using it"? I feel a few steps are missing.
Easy - the justice system isn't doing the proper checks. Police use it, and it returns a list of names of people WHO LOOK NOTHING LIKE the person of interest. And police do not even perform a preliminary check of whether or not the person could have committed the crime (they may have an alibi). And the judges do not even take 5 seconds to look at the photos of the suspect or the person identified. And then you arrest a random stranger who is then locked up for several weeks, ruining their lives (lose their job, lose their house, etc).
No, they're not supposed to be using the software and going from "surveillance video" to "arrest"
It should not take a judge in a courtroom to have to dismiss the case for obvious "this guy should never have been arrested in the first place".
It's only a matter of time before facial recognition says a black guy did the crime when it was clearly a white guy in the surveillance video. Or vice-versa.
And as long as police do not use their tools properly they shouldn't have access to them. And using the tools properly means understanding the limitations of it. Facial recognition is not a magic box where you insert video on one end and it spits out the name of the culprit on the other.
No, facial recognition is a tool, and it can be used, when used responsibly. The problem is, the police have not shown to be responsible users of the technology.
Especially when they can ruin lives due to misidentification. Once arrested, it can take 2 or 3 weeks before anyone processes your case. Which means you're stuck in jail for 2-3 weeks. Your job will likely fire you for not showing up to work. And you can lose your house because without money, no job, there goes your rent or mortgage payment. 21 days later someone goes "Oops, you look nothing like the suspect, sorry!" and then they dump you on the street. You lost your job, your house, your family is likely somewhere where you don't know.
(And yes, ICE uses the same tactics for those people they wrongly arrest)
If you're lucky great, you can get a lawyer who can expedite matters - but that shouldn't be the determining factor on whether a false arrest ruins your life.